外科受训医师的手术记录口述:一种未充分利用的教育资源?
该试点研究让38名PGY1至PGY4外科住院医师参与腹壁疝修补模拟,由高年资住院医师带教低年资医师,随后完成手术记录口述并用改良量表评分。结果显示培训中手术记录口述机会和反馈不足,总体均分18.9±5.4分(总分33分),高年资与低年资住院医师总分无显著差异(p=0.10),但高年资在相关病史和记录抬头部分得分更高(p=0.04)。作者认为标准外科培训可能未提供足够教学和反馈,正式住院医师课程或可提升受训者能力。
要点
- 82%的受训住院医师在培训中完成的手术记录口述不超过25次,77%获得的反馈很少。
- 手术记录口述总体均分18.9±5.4分(总分33分),高年资与低年资住院医师总分无显著差异(p=0.10)。
- 高年资住院医师在相关病史和记录抬头部分得分高于低年资(p=0.04),操作细节部分两组得分相似(p=0.29)。
核心结论
- 标准外科培训可能未向住院医师提供足够的手术记录口述教学和反馈,正式住院医师培训课程或可提升受训者学习有效手术记录各组成部分的能力。
研究设计与样本
- 试点研究,38名PGY1至PGY4外科住院医师参与腹壁疝修补模拟,1名高年资(PGY3/4)住院医师指导2名低年资(PGY1/2)住院医师,模拟后完成手术记录口述并用改良验证量表评分。
主要发现
- 35名住院医师完成需求评估,38名提交手术记录;82%在培训中完成的手术记录口述不超过25次,77%获得的反馈很少。
- 手术记录口述总分33分,总体均分18.9±5.4;低年资住院医师17.9±5.4,高年资住院医师20.9±4.8。
- 高年资与低年资住院医师总分无显著差异(p=0.10),操作细节部分得分相似(p=0.29)。
- 高年资住院医师在相关病史和手术记录抬头部分得分高于低年资(p=0.04)。
临床怎么用
- 作者认为,正式住院医师培训课程或可提升受训者学习有效手术记录各组成部分的能力。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Accurate operative notes are imperative to patient care and are used for communication, billing, quality assurance, and medical-legal conflicts. However, operative note quality often varies and many lack critical details. Unfortunately, no standardized training exists in operative dictations for surgical trainees. This pilot study sought to determine resident ability to dictate a comprehensive operative note and to determine a need for a formal operative dictation curriculum. METHODS: Thirty-eight surgical residents between post-graduate years (PGY) one to four participated in a ventral hernia repair simulation. One senior (PGY3/4) resident coached two junior residents (PGY1/2). Residents completed an informal needs assessment regarding operative dictations. Post-simulation, residents completed an operative dictation. Notes were graded using a modified validated rubric. RESULTS: Thirty-five residents completed the needs assessment, and 38 residents submitted an operative note. Eighty-two percent of this group have completed ≤ 25 operative dictations in training and 77% have received minimal feedback on operative dictations. Out of 33 total points, mean overall score was 18.9 ± 5.4 (Junior resident: 17.9 ± 5.4; Senior resident: 20.9 ± 4.8) Total mean scores did not significantly differ between junior and senior residents (p = 0.10). Senior and junior residents scored similarly on the procedural details component (p = 0.29). Senior residents scored higher on relevant patient history and operative note headers (p = 0.04). CONCLUSION: Standard surgical training may not provide enough teaching and feedback to residents on operative note dictations. A formal residency training curriculum may bolster trainee ability to learn the components of an effective operative note.
引用
- Han B, Clanahan J, Casson C, et al. Operative dictations in surgical trainees: an underutilized educational resource? Surg Endosc. 2023. PMID: 37638992. doi:10.1007/s00464-023-10404-3
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。