纪念科普《急腹症的早期诊断》出版100周年
本文回顾了文森特·扎卡里·科普爵士所著《急腹症的早期诊断》自1921年首版以来的百年演变,该方法学著作强调病史与体格检查在急腹症诊断中的核心价值,并随抗生素治疗和影像技术发展而调整内容侧重。作者认为科普关于临床诊断应依靠与患者互动而非过度依赖实验室检查和影像学的教诲至今仍有现实意义。
要点
- 科普《急腹症的早期诊断》首版于1921年,后由威廉·赛伦延续至第22版。
- 百年来物理诊断与病史采集的基本原则未变,但对相关内科疾病的 emphasis 因抗生素治疗和非手术疾病流行而变化。
- 早期版本强调平片X线摄影的价值,后期版本将横断面成像纳入有价值的诊断工具。
核心结论
- 科普这部杰作的背景与演变是腹部外科医生传承的基石。
- 科普关于 dedication 和注重细节、通过与患者互动而非过度使用实验室检查和影像学来形成临床诊断的教诲,在当今快速演变且日益价值导向的世界中仍然适用。
研究设计与样本
- 本文对《急腹症的早期诊断》各版本及《急腹症韵文》在其出版时代的历史背景下进行了梳理与详细审阅。
主要发现
- 百年来至当前印次,物理诊断与病史采集的基本原则未变。
- 对相关内科疾病的 emphasis 因抗生素治疗及该时期非手术疾病流行情况而演变。
- 早期版本强调平片X线摄影随其普及而具有的价值。
- 后期版本将横断面成像纳入有价值的诊断工具。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: No list of the iconic books in surgery would be complete without The Early Diagnosis of the Acute Abdomen by Sir Vincent Zachary Cope, MS, MD. First published in 1921, few books have stood the test of time like this treatise on the acute abdomen. It is also fitting that, after Mr Cope's passing, William Silen would assume the mantle with the 15th edition and maintain his legacy work through the 22nd and final edition. METHODS: Each edition of The Early Diagnosis of the Acute Abdomen and The Acute Abdomen in Rhyme was curated and reviewed in detail within the historical context of the era in which the book was printed. RESULTS: The tenets of physical diagnosis and history did not change during the 100 years through the current printing; however, the emphasis on related medical diseases evolved due to antibiotic therapy and the prevalence of nonsurgical diseases that evolved across this period. Early editions highlighted the value of plain radiography as it came into common use, whereas later editions included cross-sectional imaging as a valuable diagnostic tool. CONCLUSION: The context and evolution of this masterpiece are fundamental to the legacy of the abdominal surgeon. Cope's lessons on the value of dedication and attention to detail to formulate clinical diagnoses by engaging with the patient rather than excessive use of laboratory testing and imaging still apply in today's rapidly evolving and increasingly value-based world.
引用
- Schwaitzberg S. Celebrating 100 years of Cope's Early Diagnosis of the AcuteAbdomen. Surgery. 2023. PMID: 37487826. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2023.06.029
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。