普通外科置信职业行为(EPA)的实施:一项全国性试点研究结果
美国外科委员会联合多家机构开发5项EPA并在28个普通外科住院医师培训基地试点,2018年7月1日至2020年6月30日实施。共收集6272份形成性微评估和1763份总结性信任评级,涉及497名住院医师。结果显示EPA可广泛实施但差异较大,毕业 chief resident 在多项常见手术中被信任可独立操作。
要点
- 5项EPA基于ACGME病例日志常见手术和额外里程碑活动选定。
- PGY1住院医师被信任水平为直接监督,PGY5为无监督实践或教学他人。
- 除咨询EPA外,各EPA的信任度随住院医师年级升高而增加。
核心结论
- 数据表明在普通外科项目中广泛实施EPA是可行的,但实施情况存在差异。
- 数据提供有意义的信息:毕业 chief resident 在多项常见普通外科手术中被其教师信任可无监督操作,并突出了成功广泛实施EPA需针对的领域。
研究设计与样本
- 美国外科委员会召集美国外科医师学会、ACGME外科审查委员会和外科项目主任协会的代表,在全国住院医师培训项目中开展试点研究。
- 选取5项EPA:右下腹疼痛、胆道疾病、腹股沟疝、执行会诊、创伤患者护理。
- 2017至2018年进行站点招募和教师发展;2018年7月1日开始在各住院医师项目中实施EPA,2020年6月30日完成。
- 每个站点分配2项EPA实施,收集住院医师的EPA微评估,站点临床能力委员会(CCC)据此做出总结性信任决定。
- 28个站点参与,代表地理和规模差异、社区和大学附属项目;2年试点期间报告了14至180名住院医师。
主要发现
- 共收集6272份形成性微评估(每站点范围0至1144份)。
- 每名住院医师有0至184份微评估;每名住院医师平均微评估数为5.6(SD=13.4),中位数1(IQR=6)。
- 共对497名唯一住院医师分配了1763份总结性信任评级。
- 用于信任的平均观察次数为3.24(SD 3.61),中位数2(IQR 3)。
- 总体而言,PGY1住院医师被信任水平为直接监督,PGY5住院医师为无监督实践或教学他人;除咨询EPA外,CCC报告的每项EPA信任度随住院医师年级升高而增加。
关键数值与推荐
- 信任水平1至5分别对应:仅观察、直接监督、间接监督、无监督、教学他人。
- 5项EPA为:右下腹疼痛、胆道疾病、腹股沟疝、执行会诊、创伤患者护理。
临床怎么用
- 原文未据此给出推荐。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The ongoing complexity of general surgery training has led to an increased focus on ensuring the competence of graduating residents. Entrustable professional activities (EPAs) are units of professional practice that provide an assessment framework to drive competency-based education. The American Board of Surgery convened a group from the American College of Surgeons, Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) Surgery Review Committee, and Association of Program Directors in Surgery to develop and implement EPAs in a pilot group of residency programs across the country. The objective of this pilot study was to determine the feasibility and utility of EPAs in general surgery resident training. METHODS: 5 EPAs were chosen based on the most common procedures reported in ACGME case logs and by practicing general surgeons (right lower quadrant pain, biliary disease, inguinal hernia), along with common activities covering additional ACGME milestones (performing a consult, care of a trauma patient). Levels of entrustment assigned (1 to 5) were observation only, direct supervision, indirect supervision, unsupervised, and teaching others. Participating in site recruitment and faculty development occurred from 2017 to 2018. EPA implementation at individual residency programs began on July 1, 2018, and was completed on June 30, 2020. Each site was assigned 2 EPAs to implement and collected EPA microassessments on residents for those EPAs. The site clinical competency committees (CCC) used these microassessments to make summative entrustment decisions. Data submitted to the independent deidentified data repository every 6 months included the number of microassessments collected per resident per EPA and CCC summative entrustment decisions. RESULTS: Twenty-eight sites were selected to participate in the program and represented geographic and size variability, community, and university-based programs. Over the course of the 2-year pilot programs reported on 14 to 180 residents. Overall, 6,272 formative microassessments were collected (range, 0 to 1144 per site). Each resident had between 0 and 184 microassessments. The mean number of microassessments per resident was 5.6 (SD = 13.4) with a median of 1 [interquartile range (IQR) = 6]. There were 1,763 summative entrustment ratings assigned to 497 unique residents. The average number of observations for entrustment was 3.24 (SD 3.61) with a median of 2 (IQR 3). In general, PGY1 residents were entrusted at the level of direct supervision and PGY5 residents were entrusted at unsupervised practice or teaching others. For each EPA other than the consult EPA, the degree of entrustment reported by the CCC increased by resident level. CONCLUSIONS: These data provide evidence that widespread implementation of EPAs across general surgery programs is possible, but variable. They provide meaningful data that graduating chief residents are entrusted by their faculty to perform without supervision for several common general surgical procedures and highlight areas to target for the successful widespread implementation of EPAs.
引用
- Brasel KJ, Lindeman B, Jones A, et al. Implementation of Entrustable Professional Activities in General Surgery: Results of a National Pilot Study. Ann Surg. 2023. PMID: 37436883. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000005991
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。