CUSUM学习曲线:能说明什么与不能说明什么
该研究比较了完成前20例机器人辅助手术时间分别为13、26、39、52周的外科医生队列的CUSUM曲线,分别使用前50例和前100例计算。涉及前列腺切除、恶性子宫切除和腹股沟疝手术。结果显示快速积累病例的队列CUSUM斜率更低,且CUSUM峰值对应的病例数随总病例数从50增至100而普遍增加。结论认为CUSUM峰值受评估总例数影响,不能单独作为掌握学习曲线的充分指标。
要点
- CUSUM峰值随评估总例数增加而增大,定义熟练度存在偏倚。
- 快速积累病例的外科医生手术时间变异性更小。
- CUSUM峰值本身不足以判定已克服学习曲线。
核心结论
- CUSUM曲线峰值受评估总例数影响,不能单独作为掌握学习曲线的充分指标。
研究设计与样本
- 比较不同病例积累速率(13、26、39、52周完成前20例)的外科医生队列的CUSUM曲线,分别使用前50例和前100例计算。
- 分析涵盖前列腺切除(1094名外科医生)、恶性子宫切除(737名)和腹股沟疝(1486名)三种机器人辅助手术。
主要发现
- 所有手术中,13周完成前20例的队列CUSUM曲线斜率低于积累更慢的队列。
- CUSUM峰值对应的病例数在总病例数从50增至100时普遍增加。
临床怎么用
- 解读CUSUM学习曲线时需考虑评估总例数对峰值的影响,避免将峰值简单视为熟练度标志。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: There has been increased interest in assessing the surgeon learning curve for new skill acquisition. While there is no consensus around the best methodology, one of the most frequently used learning curve assessments in the surgical literature is the cumulative sum curve (CUSUM) of operative time. To demonstrate the limitations of this methodology, we assessed the CUSUM of console time across cohorts of surgeons with differing case acquisition rates while varying the total number of cases used to calculate the CUSUM. METHODS: We compared the CUSUM curves of the average console times of surgeons who completed their first 20 robotic-assisted (RAS) cases in 13, 26, 39, and 52 weeks, respectively, for their first 50 and 100 cases, respectively. This analysis was performed for prostatectomy (1094 surgeons), malignant hysterectomy (737 surgeons), and inguinal hernia (1486 surgeons). RESULTS: In all procedures, the CUSUM curve of the cohort of surgeons who completed their first 20 procedures in 13 weeks demonstrated a lower slope than cohorts of surgeons with slower case acquisition rates. The case number at which the peak of the CUSUM curve occurs uniformly increases when the total number of cases used in generation of the CUSUM chart changes from 50 to 100 cases. CONCLUSION: The CUSUM analyses of these three procedures suggests that surgeons with fast initial case acquisition rates have less variability in their operative times over the course of their learning curve. The peak of the CUSUM curve, which is often used in surgical learning curve literature to denote "proficiency" is predictably influenced by the total number of procedures evaluated, suggesting that defining the peak as the point at which a surgeon has overcome the learning curve is subject to routine bias. The CUSUM peak, by itself, is an insufficient measure of "conquering the learning curve."
引用
- Lin PL, Zheng F, Shin M, et al. CUSUM learning curves: what they can and can't tell us. Surg Endosc. 2023. PMID: 37460815. doi:10.1007/s00464-023-10252-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。