SAGES 2019年会摘要后续发表情况分析
该研究评估了SAGES 2019年会摘要后续在同行评议期刊发表的情况,纳入724篇摘要(160篇口头发言、564篇壁报)。口头发言摘要发表率为80%(128篇),壁报摘要发表率为27.3%(154篇)。壁报发表与结直肠外科、代谢/肥胖主题及高级学位正相关,与女性资深作者负相关。
要点
- SAGES 2019口头发言摘要发表率80%,壁报摘要发表率27.3%。
- 口头发言发表中位时间4个月,壁报发表中位时间13个月。
- 壁报发表预测因素:结直肠外科、代谢/肥胖主题、高级学位。
核心结论
- 80%的口头发言摘要和27%的壁报摘要最终发表。
- 壁报发表的某些预测因素被注意到,但尚不清楚这些是否导致项目未能发表。
- 需要未来研究确定是否有有效策略提高壁报发表率。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性分析SAGES 2019年会摘要,在 presentation 后28个月通过MedLine、Embase和Google Scholar识别已发表手稿。
- 纳入724篇摘要(160篇口头发言,564篇壁报),评估作者和摘要因素与发表的关联,进行描述性分析和多变量统计。
主要发现
- 口头发言摘要中128篇(80%)发表,中位时间4个月。
- 壁报摘要中154篇(27.3%)发表,中位时间13个月。
- 单变量分析显示壁报发表与摘要主题(p=0.015)和资深作者学位(p=0.01)显著相关。
- 多变量分析显示结直肠外科(OR 2.52;CI 1.02-6.23)和代谢/肥胖(OR 2.53;CI 1.09-5.84)与发表几率增加相关。
- 女性资深作者与发表几率负相关(OR 0.53;CI 0.29-0.98),资深作者额外学位(如博士和/或硕士)与发表率增加相关(OR 1.80;CI 1.00-3.22)。
关键数值与推荐
- 口头发言摘要发表率80%(128/160),壁报摘要发表率27.3%(154/564)。
- 壁报发表多变量分析:结直肠外科OR 2.52(CI 1.02-6.23),代谢/肥胖OR 2.53(CI 1.09-5.84),女性资深作者OR 0.53(CI 0.29-0.98),资深作者额外学位OR 1.80(CI 1.00-3.22)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Research presentation has benefits, including CV building, networking, and collaboration. A measurable standard for achievement is publication in a peer-reviewed journal. Expectations regarding the likelihood of publication are unknown for studies presented at a national surgical scientific meeting. This study aims to evaluate predictors of manuscript publication arising from abstracts presented at a national surgical scientific meeting. METHODS: Abstracts presented at the Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons (SAGES) Meeting 2019 were reviewed. Identification of published manuscripts was completed using MedLine, Embase, and Google Scholar 28 months after the presentation to allow for time for publication. Factors evaluated for association with publication included author and abstract measures. Descriptive analyses and multivariable statistics were performed. RESULTS: 724 abstracts (160 podiums, 564 posters) were included. Of the podium presentations, 128 (80%) were published in a median of 4 months after the presentation. On univariable and multivariable analyses, there was no association between publication and abstract topic, gender, degree, number of publications, or H-indices of first and senior authors. 154 (27.3%) poster presentations were published with a median of 13 months. On univariable analysis, there was a statistically significant difference regarding the abstract topic (p = 0.015) and senior author degree (p = 0.01) between published and unpublished posters. Multivariable analysis demonstrated that colorectal surgery (OR 2.52; CI 1.02-6.23) and metabolic/obesity (OR 2.53; CI 1.09-5.84) are associated with an increased odd of publication. There was an inverse association with female senior authors (OR 0.53; CI 0.29-0.98), while additional degrees (e.g., doctorate and/or master's degree) of the senior authors were associated with an increased publication rate (OR 1.80; CI 1.00-3.22). CONCLUSION: 80% of podiums but only 27% of posters were ultimately published. While some predictors of poster publication were noted, it is unclear if these are why these projects fail to publish. Future research is warranted to determine if there are effective strategies to increase poster publication rates.
引用
- Jodeh DS, Scariano G, An C, et al. An analysis of publications originating from abstracts presented at the Society of American Gastrointestinal and Endoscopic Surgeons (SAGES) Meeting. Surg Endosc. 2023. PMID: 37204602. doi:10.1007/s00464-023-10139-1
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。