伤口愈合问卷通用报告结局测量在全球手术试验中的跨文化改编:TALON-1混合方法研究与Rasch分析
本研究为嵌入国际随机试验的混合方法研究,通过47名研究者定性访谈和537例患者Rasch分析,评估Bluebelle伤口愈合问卷(WHQ)在低收入和中等收入国家的跨文化等价性、可接受性和内容效度,并提出跨文化改编建议,包括9个条目修订和症状条目反应类别调整。
要点
- WHQ单维度量表满足单维性检验,序数总分有效,但5个条目存在模型拟合不佳。
- 定性三角验证支持对条目1、3、7、10、11、15、16、18、19进行跨文化改编。
- 症状条目1-10反应类别改为3级(完全无、有一点、很多),条目11发热改为2级(无、有)。
核心结论
- 研究基于三大洲共同生产的混合方法数据,为WHQ在全球外科研究和实践中的跨文化改编提出建议。
- 翻译版本现已可用于远程伤口评估路径的实施。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究(SWAT)嵌入国际随机试验,与社区和患者伙伴共同生产,遵循最佳实践指南。
- 定性阶段:10次结构化访谈和6个焦点小组,共47名研究者来自6个国家。
- 定量阶段:前瞻性队列数据,Rasch分析纳入537例患者(排除极端值后369例)。
- 翻译按Mapi建议完成五种语言版本。
- 采用改良探索性工具设计模型三角验证定性和定量数据。
主要发现
- 定性阶段识别出理解、反应映射、提取和判断相关主题,获得丰富的跨文化见解。
- Rasch分析中,由于极端(地板)值数量多,整体检验效能低。
- 单维WHQ量表满足单维性检验,表明序数总分WHQ有效。
- 5个条目(5、9、14、15、16)存在显著整体模型拟合不佳,11个条目对存在局部依赖。
- 个体分离指数估计为0.48,提示类别间区分度弱;Cronbach's α为0.86,较高。
关键数值与推荐
- 个体分离指数0.48,Cronbach's α 0.86。
- 5个条目(5、9、14、15、16)存在显著整体模型拟合不佳,11个条目对存在局部依赖。
- 症状条目1至10反应类别:1(完全无)、2(有一点)、3(很多);条目11(发热):0(无)、1(有)。
临床怎么用
- WHQ可用于全球外科研究和实践中远程检测手术部位感染,需采用跨文化改编版本。
- 五种语言翻译版本已可用,可整合入远程伤口评估路径。
- 临床使用时需注意WHQ条目1、3、7、10、11、15、16、18、19的跨文化改编建议。
局限性
- 由于极端(地板)值数量多,Rasch分析整体检验效能低。
- 个体分离指数0.48提示类别间区分度弱。
- 5个条目存在模型拟合不佳,11个条目对存在局部依赖。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Bluebelle Wound Healing Questionnaire (WHQ) is a universal-reporter outcome measure developed in the UK for remote detection of surgical-site infection after abdominal surgery. This study aimed to explore cross-cultural equivalence, acceptability, and content validity of the WHQ for use across low- and middle-income countries, and to make recommendations for its adaptation. METHODS: This was a mixed-methods study within a trial (SWAT) embedded in an international randomized trial, conducted according to best practice guidelines, and co-produced with community and patient partners (TALON-1). Structured interviews and focus groups were used to gather data regarding cross-cultural, cross-contextual equivalence of the individual items and scale, and conduct a translatability assessment. Translation was completed into five languages in accordance with Mapi recommendations. Next, data from a prospective cohort (SWAT) were interpreted using Rasch analysis to explore scaling and measurement properties of the WHQ. Finally, qualitative and quantitative data were triangulated using a modified, exploratory, instrumental design model. RESULTS: In the qualitative phase, 10 structured interviews and six focus groups took place with a total of 47 investigators across six countries. Themes related to comprehension, response mapping, retrieval, and judgement were identified with rich cross-cultural insights. In the quantitative phase, an exploratory Rasch model was fitted to data from 537 patients (369 excluding extremes). Owing to the number of extreme (floor) values, the overall level of power was low. The single WHQ scale satisfied tests of unidimensionality, indicating validity of the ordinal total WHQ score. There was significant overall model misfit of five items (5, 9, 14, 15, 16) and local dependency in 11 item pairs. The person separation index was estimated as 0.48 suggesting weak discrimination between classes, whereas Cronbach's α was high at 0.86. Triangulation of qualitative data with the Rasch analysis supported recommendations for cross-cultural adaptation of the WHQ items 1 (redness), 3 (clear fluid), 7 (deep wound opening), 10 (pain), 11 (fever), 15 (antibiotics), 16 (debridement), 18 (drainage), and 19 (reoperation). Changes to three item response categories (1, not at all; 2, a little; 3, a lot) were adopted for symptom items 1 to 10, and two categories (0, no; 1, yes) for item 11 (fever). CONCLUSION: This study made recommendations for cross-cultural adaptation of the WHQ for use in global surgical research and practice, using co-produced mixed-methods data from three continents. Translations are now available for implementation into remote wound assessment pathways.
引用
- Glasbey J. Adaptation of the Wound Healing Questionnaire universal-reporter outcome measure for use in global surgery trials (TALON-1 study): mixed-methods study and Rasch analysis. Br J Surg. 2023. PMID: 37005373. doi:10.1093/bjs/znad058
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。