结直肠外科诊疗障碍的社会生态学定性分析
本研究从5个社会生态层面(个体、人际、组织、社区、政策)招募结直肠外科利益相关者,通过焦点小组和个体访谈探讨健康社会决定因素作为诊疗障碍或促进因素的作用。共开展6个患者焦点小组(n=18)和12个关键利益相关者访谈,归纳出各层面的关键因素,为减少手术差异提供干预靶点。
要点
- 健康社会决定因素在个体、人际、组织、社区和政策五个层面影响结直肠外科诊疗。
- 个体层面障碍包括清晰沟通和心理压力,人际层面涉及提供者沟通与信任。
- 组织层面涉及多种联系方式、教育材料、预约系统和歧视,社区层面涉及支持和交通。
核心结论
- 影响结直肠外科患者诊疗的关键健康社会决定因素在每個社会生态层面均有出现,可能为减少手术差异提供干预靶点。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,招募代表5个社会生态层面的参与者:患者(个体)、照护者/外科医生(人际)、医院领导者(组织)、社区领导者(社区)和政府领导者(政策)。
- 患者参与焦点小组,其余参与者接受个体访谈,使用半结构化访谈指南。
- 共进行6个患者焦点小组(总n=18)和12个关键利益相关者访谈。
- 由3名编码者采用归纳主题方法进行内容分析,编码者间一致性为93%。
主要发现
- 患者平均年龄54.7岁,66%为黑人,61%为女性。
- 最常见疾病为结直肠癌(28%)、炎症性肠病(28%)和憩室炎(22%)。
- 个体层面障碍包括清晰沟通和心理压力。
- 人际层面障碍包括提供者沟通与信任、COVID相关探视限制。
- 组织层面障碍包括多种联系方式、优质教育材料、预约系统、歧视。
临床怎么用
- 临床实践中可关注各社会生态层面的障碍因素,如改善提供者沟通与信任、提供清晰的教育材料、优化预约系统、协调交通支持等。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Although specific social determinants of health have been associated with disparities in surgical outcomes, there exists a gap in knowledge regarding the mechanisms of these associations. Gaining perspectives from multiple socioecological levels can help elucidate these mechanisms. Our study aims to identify social determinants of health that act as barriers or facilitators to surgical care among colorectal surgery stakeholders. METHODS: We recruited participants representing 5 socioecological levels: patients (individual); caregivers/surgeons (interpersonal); and leaders in hospitals (organizational), communities (community), and government (policy). Patients participated in focus groups, and the remaining participants underwent individual interviews. Semistructured interview guides were used to explore barriers and facilitators to surgical care at each socioecological level. Transcripts were analyzed by 3 coders in an inductive thematic approach with content analyses. The intercoder agreement was 93%. RESULTS: Six patient focus groups (total n = 18) and 12 key stakeholder interviews were conducted. The mean age of patients was 54.7 years, 66% were Black, and 61% were female. The most common diseases were colorectal cancer (28%), inflammatory bowel disease (28%), and diverticulitis (22%). Key social determinants of health impacting surgical care emerged at each level: individual (clear communication, mental stress), interpersonal (provider communication and trust, COVID-related visitation restrictions), organizational (multiple forms of contact, quality educational materials, scheduling systems, discrimination), community (community and family support and transportation), and policy (charity care, patient advocacy organizations, insurance coverage). CONCLUSION: Key social determinants of health-impacting care among colorectal surgery patients emerged at each socioecological level and may provide targets for interventions to reduce surgical disparities.
引用
- Smith BP, Girling I, Hollis RH, et al. A socioecological qualitative analysis of barriers to care in colorectal surgery. Surgery. 2023. PMID: 37088570. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2023.03.009
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。