结直肠加速康复项目真相:151家医院过程指标依从性
研究评估151家医院实施18个月结直肠加速康复项目(ERP)方案后6项过程指标的改善情况。在663个可改善机会中,52%改善极小,20%显著改善,28%依从性恶化。结论与既往文献报告的显著改善不一致,多数医院难以实现过程依从性的大幅提升。
要点
- 仅20%的过程指标改善机会实现>20%的依从性提升,多数改善有限或恶化。
- 多模式镇痛和口服抗生素是改善最明显的两项过程指标。
- 文献报告的ERP实施成功率与真实世界观察存在不一致,需关注推广普及。
核心结论
- 与已发表文献相反,多数研究医院难以提高过程依从性,80%的机会未实现显著改善。
- 文献报告的成功率与大规模样本观察之间的不一致可能反映医院文化或特征差异,或发表偏倚。
研究设计与样本
- 151家医院实施结直肠ERP,包含路径、教育和支持材料及数据采集方案。
- 队列共有906个过程依从性改善机会(151家医院×6项过程指标),排除240个因起始依从率>80%的机会和3个因依从率记录少于2例的机会,最终研究663个机会。
主要发现
- 在663个机会中,52%为极小改善(依从性增加0%至20%),20%为显著改善(依从性增加>20%),28%出现依从性恶化。
- 6项过程中,多模式镇痛和口服抗生素使用改善最多。
关键数值与推荐
- 6项结直肠ERP过程指标包括:口服抗生素、机械性肠道准备、多模式镇痛、早期活动、早期液体摄入和早期固体摄入。
- 显著改善定义为依从性增加>20%。
- 起始依从率>80%的机会被排除。
临床怎么用
- 临床应关注ERP过程指标的持续监测与依从性提升,尤其针对改善有限或恶化的指标。
- 需针对不同医院类型促进ERP采纳,而非假设普遍可实现大幅改善。
局限性
- 排除了起始依从率>80%的机会和依从率记录少于2例的机会,可能影响结果代表性。
- 研究仅涉及6项过程指标和18个月实施周期,结论外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Commonly cited studies have reported substantial improvements (defined as >20%) in process measure compliance after implementation of colorectal enhanced recovery programs (ERPs). However, hospitals have anecdotally reported difficulties in achieving similar improvement gains. This study evaluates improvement uniformity among 151 hospitals exposed to an 18-month implementation protocol for 6 colorectal ERP process measures (oral antibiotics, mechanical bowel preparation, multimodal pain control, early mobilization, early liquid intake, and early solid intake). STUDY DESIGN: One hundred fifty-one hospitals implemented a colorectal ERP with pathway, educational and supporting materials, and data capture protocols; 906 opportunities existed for process compliance improvement across the cohort (151 hospitals × 6 process measures). However, 240 opportunities were excluded due to high starting compliance rates (ie compliance >80%) and 3 opportunities were excluded because compliance rates were recorded for fewer than 2 cases. Thus, 663 opportunities for improvement across 151 hospitals were studied. RESULTS: Of 663 opportunities, minimal improvement (0% to 20% increase in compliance) occurred in 52% of opportunities, substantial improvement (>20% increase in compliance) in 20%, and worsening compliance occurred in 28%. Of the 6 processes, multimodal pain control and use of oral antibiotics improved the most. CONCLUSIONS: Contrary to published ERP literature, the majority of study hospitals had difficulty improving process compliance with 80% of the opportunities not achieving substantial improvement. This discordance between ERP implementation success rates reported in the literature and what is observed in a large sample could reflect differences in hospitals' culture or characteristics, or a publication bias. Attention needs to be directed toward improving ERP adoption across the spectrum of hospital types.
引用
- Shah TA, Knapp L, Cohen ME, et al. Truth of Colorectal Enhanced Recovery Programs: Process Measure Compliance in 151 Hospitals. J Am Coll Surg. 2023. PMID: 36852926. doi:10.1097/XCS.0000000000000562
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。