外科医生与患者对常见普外科手术费用及报销估算的准确性及CMS价格透明规则的作用
该研究在学术医疗中心术前门诊后10个月内,对患者及其外科医生进行问卷调查,比较其对10种腹腔镜手术的医院费用和报销估算与实际值。结果显示患者高估费用中位4502美元、低估报销中位1834美元,医生低估直接费用825美元、低估报销1659美元,提示双方均无法准确估算,价格透明规则需进一步教育方能生效。
要点
- 患者高估医院费用中位4502美元,低估报销中位1834美元。
- 医生低估直接费用825美元,低估报销1659美元。
- 双方估算均不准确,价格透明规则需配合教育才可能有效。
核心结论
- 患者和外科医生均不能准确估算医疗费用或报酬,若无进一步教育,双方都无法成为基于价格透明减少手术支出的有效变革者。
主要发现
- 患者对医院费用的估算中位超出实际医院费用4502美元,对医院报销的估算中位低于实际报销1834美元。
- 外科医生对直接费用的估算中位低于医院直接费用825美元,对报销的估算中位低于医院报销1659美元。
临床怎么用
- 外科医生应意识到自身对手术费用和报销的估算存在系统性低估,需主动获取准确费用信息以辅助患者决策。
- 在价格透明政策下,仅提供价格数据不足以改变手术支出,需配合对医生和患者的教育干预。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: On January 1, 2021, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services implemented a hospital price transparency rule. Consumerism as a means of reducing healthcare expenditure is predicated on informed consumers making discrete choices. STUDY DESIGN: For 10 months, immediately after a preoperative clinic visit at an academic medical center, patients and their surgeons were surveyed regarding their estimation of hospital cost and hospital reimbursement for the upcoming operation. Responses were compared to average institutional cost (fiscal year 2019) for Medicare patients undergoing a laparoscopic approach for each operation. We calculated the difference between actual reimbursement and cost with patients' estimates and actual reimbursement and cost with surgeons' estimates. RESULTS: Sixty-six questionnaires were collected from patients who underwent laparoscopic operations, that included cholecystectomy (n = 20), inguinal hernia (n = 17), umbilical hernia repair (n = 6), ventral hernia repair (n = 6), incisional hernia (n = 6), hiatal hernia repair (n = 1), and lipoma or cyst excision (n = 10). Patients' estimates of hospital cost exceeded actual hospital cost by a median of $4,502 and were less than hospital reimbursement by a median of $1,834. Surgeon estimates for direct cost were $825 less than hospital direct cost and $1,659 less than hospital reimbursement. CONCLUSIONS: Patients as well as their surgeons do not estimate healthcare cost or remuneration accurately and therefore will be ineffective change agents in reducing surgical spending based on price transparency without further education of both parties. Patients consistently overestimated surgical cost while surgeons consistently underestimated surgical cost and reimbursement. It is likely that better-informed surgeons and patients are necessary prerequisites for Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services price transparency rules to be effective in reducing Medicare expenditures in surgery.
引用
- Frazier GD, Turrentine FE, Williams MD, et al. Accuracy of Surgeon and Patient Estimated Cost and Reimbursement for Common General Surgical Operations and Benefit of Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services Price Transparency Rules. J Am Coll Surg. 2023. PMID: 36622650. doi:10.1097/XCS.0000000000000534
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。