全球总额预付是否导致复杂手术集中化?马里兰州全球预算收入计划的启示
该研究利用州住院数据库,比较马里兰州实施全球预算收入(GBR)模式前后与对照州在复杂手术集中化程度上的差异。样本含122,882例手术,结果显示GBR实施后胃切除术和肺切除术/肺叶切除术在高集中度医院实施的概率显著增加,差异分别为5.5和12.4个百分点,髋/膝关节翻修术也呈阳性差异。
要点
- GBR实施后胃切除术在高集中度医院实施概率增加5.5个百分点(95%CI 2.2-8.8)。
- GBR实施后肺切除术/肺叶切除术在高集中度医院实施概率增加12.4个百分点(95%CI 10.0-14.8)。
- GBR实施与部分复杂手术集中化增加相关,对患者体验和可及性的影响需进一步研究。
核心结论
- GBR实施与某些复杂手术的集中化增加相关。
研究设计与样本
- 利用州住院数据库,比较马里兰州与对照州在GBR实施前后复杂手术在高集中度医院实施比例的变化,采用双重差分法分析。
- 样本共纳入122,882例手术,包括胃切除术、肺切除术/肺叶切除术、直肠切除术和髋/膝关节翻修术。
主要发现
- GBR实施后,马里兰州所有纳入分析的复杂手术在高集中度医院实施的比例均增加。
- 胃切除术和肺切除术/肺叶切除术满足平行趋势假设,GBR后在高集中度医院实施的概率分别增加5.5个百分点(95%CI 2.2-8.8)和12.4个百分点(95%CI 10.0-14.8)。
- 髋/膝关节翻修术分析假设持续反事实,GBR后双重差分值为4.8个百分点(95%CI 1.3-8.2)。
- 直肠切除术因GBR前趋势不同,无法得出结论。
临床怎么用
- 全球预算收入模式可能通过集中化复杂手术来改善成本与结局,临床需关注集中化对患者可及性的影响。
局限性
- 直肠切除术因GBR前趋势差异无法分析,髋/膝关节翻修术分析假设持续反事实。
- 研究未探讨集中化对患者体验和可及性的影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: To determine if global budget revenue (GBR) models incent the centralization of complex surgical care. SUMMARY BACKGROUND: In 2014, Maryland initiated a statewide GBR model. While prior research has shown improvements in cost and outcomes for surgical care post-GBR implementation, the mechanism remains unclear. METHODS: Utilizing state inpatient databases, we compared the proportion of adults undergoing elective complex surgeries (gastrectomy, pneumonectomy/lobectomy, proctectomies, and hip/knee revision) at high-concentration hospitals (HCHs) in Maryland and control states. Annual concentration, per procedure, was defined as hospital volume divided by state volume. HCHs were defined as hospitals with a concentration at least at the 75 th percentile in 2010. We estimated the difference-in-differences (DiD) of the probability of patients undergoing surgery at HCHs before and after GBR implementation. FINDINGS: Our sample included 122,882 surgeries. Following GBR implementation, all procedures were increasingly performed at HCHs in Maryland. States satisfied the parallel trends assumption for the centralization of gastrectomy and pneumonectomy/lobectomy. Post-GBR, patients were more likely to undergo gastrectomy (DiD: 5.5 p.p., 95% CI [2.2, 8.8]) and pneumonectomy/lobectomy (DiD: 12.4 p.p., 95% CI [10.0, 14.8]) at an HCH in Maryland compared with control states. For our hip/knee revision analyses, we assumed persistent counterfactuals and noted a positive DiD post-GBR implementation (DiD: 4.8 p.p., 95% CI [1.3, 8.2]). No conclusion could be drawn for proctectomy due to different pre-GBR trends. CONCLUSIONS: GBR implementation is associated with increased centralization for certain complex surgeries. Future research is needed to explore the impact of centralization on patient experience and access.
引用
- Offodile AC, Lin YL, Shah SA, et al. Is the Centralization of Complex Surgical Procedures an Unintended Spillover Effect of Global Capitation? - Insights from the Maryland Global Budget Revenue Program. Ann Surg. 2022. PMID: 36512741. doi:10.1097/SLA.0000000000005737
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。