不同外科场景中高能器械的应用:SICE 完整卫生技术评估报告的启示
本文旨在评估高能器械(HEDs)在意大利外科实践中的潜在获益,比较其与标准单极或双极器械的疗效与安全性,并分析对医院和患者的经济与组织优势。文献显示多数场景使用HEDs可缩短手术时间和住院时间,常规实施可带来显著组织节约,但需边际投资。
要点
- 多数外科场景使用HEDs可缩短手术时间和住院时间。
- 常规实施HEDs可产生显著组织节约,但需边际投资。
- 医护人员感知HEDs安全性和有效性更优,患者及照护者生活质量改善。
核心结论
- HEDs引入具有战略相关性、经济可持续性和可行性,并具备流程改进潜力。
研究设计与样本
- 采用多方法:系统文献综述、23名医护人员完成的定性问卷(7项Likert量表,-3至+3)、健康经济学工具。
- 依据EUnetHTA Core Model九个维度进行评价。
主要发现
- 文献显示多数外科场景使用HEDs可减少手术时间和住院时间。
- HEDs常规实施可产生显著组织节约,但需边际投资以支持每年178,619例手术。
- 手术室时间减少5.25%–9.02%,住院时间减少5.03%–30.73%。
- 由于手术时段增加,可推测手术可及性提高9%。
- 医护人员感知确认文献证据,认为HEDs安全性和有效性更优,患者及照护者生活质量改善。
临床怎么用
- 常规实施HEDs可带来组织节约并可能提高手术可及性。
- 决策时需权衡HEDs的边际投资与组织节约及流程改进获益。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The present paper aims at evaluating the potential benefits of high-energy devices (HEDs) in the Italian surgical practice, defining the comparative efficacy and safety profiles, as well as the potential economic and organizational advantages for hospitals and patients, with respect to standard monopolar or bipolar devices. METHODS: A Health Technology Assessment was conducted in 2021 assuming the hospital perspective, comparing HEDs and standard monopolar/bipolar devices, within eleven surgical settings: appendectomy, hepatic resections, colorectal resections, cholecystectomy, splenectomy, hemorrhoidectomy, thyroidectomy, esophago-gastrectomy, breast surgery, adrenalectomy, and pancreatectomy. The nine EUnetHTA Core Model dimensions were deployed considering a multi-methods approach. Both qualitative and quantitative methods were used: (1) a systematic literature review for the definition of the comparative efficacy and safety data; (2) administration of qualitative questionnaires, completed by 23 healthcare professionals (according to 7-item Likert scale, ranging from - 3 to + 3); and (3) health-economics tools, useful for the economic evaluation of the clinical pathway and budget impact analysis, and for the definition of the organizational and accessibility advantages, in terms of time or procedures' savings. RESULTS: The literature declared a decrease in operating time and length of stay in using HEDs in most surgical settings. While HEDs would lead to a marginal investment for the conduction of 178,619 surgeries on annual basis, their routinely implementation would generate significant organizational savings. A decrease equal to - 5.25/-9.02% of operating room time and to - 5.03/-30.73% of length of stay emerged. An advantage in accessibility to surgery could be hypothesized in a 9% of increase, due to the gaining in operatory slots. Professionals' perceptions crystallized and confirmed literature evidence, declaring a better safety and effectiveness profile. An improvement in both patients and caregivers' quality-of-life emerged. CONCLUSIONS: The results have demonstrated the strategic relevance related to HEDs introduction, their economic sustainability, and feasibility, as well as the potentialities in process improvement.
引用
- Vettoretto N, Foglia E, Gerardi C, et al. High-energy devices in different surgical settings: lessons learnt from a full health technology assessment report developed by SICE (Società Italiana di Chirurgia Endoscopica). Surg Endosc. 2022. PMID: 36333498. doi:10.1007/s00464-022-09734-5
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。