II型食管裂孔疝是否真实存在?或实为椎旁裂孔疝
该研究通过回顾性复习1994至2021年华盛顿大学医学中心所有首次食管裂孔疝修补术、查阅YouTube与WebSurg手术视频及SAGES 2005至2021年年会摘要,未发现II型食管裂孔疝的确切证据。846例修补中III型760例、IV型75例、椎旁裂孔疝11例。作者认为按现行定义II型食管裂孔疝并不存在,椎旁裂孔疝易被误判为II型,建议修改分类系统。
要点
- 按现行定义II型食管裂孔疝缺乏术中证据,可能并不存在
- 椎旁裂孔疝虽少见,但易被误读为II型食管裂孔疝
- 建议重新审视食管裂孔疝分类以减少临床混淆
核心结论
- 按现行定义,II型食管裂孔疝并不存在,椎旁裂孔疝易被误判为II型食管裂孔疝。
- 作者建议考虑修改食管裂孔疝分类系统,以避免持续的临床混淆。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性复习华盛顿大学医学中心1994至2021年所有首次食管裂孔疝修补术,排除I型及再次手术病例。
- 检索YouTube与WebSurg网站手术视频,并复习SAGES 2005至2021年年会摘要。
- 共完成846例食管裂孔疝修补:III型760例、IV型75例、椎旁裂孔疝11例。
主要发现
- 三项检索均未发现II型食管裂孔疝的证据。
- 网站视频复习仅发现1例可能的II型疝,但该例很可能实为椎旁裂孔疝。
- SAGES年会摘要中未发现II型食管裂孔疝的视频或病例报告。
关键数值与推荐
- 846例首次食管裂孔疝修补中III型760例、IV型75例、椎旁裂孔疝11例。
- 三项检索来源均未确认II型食管裂孔疝。
临床怎么用
- 术前影像提示II型食管裂孔疝时,术中应警惕椎旁裂孔疝的可能并仔细辨认解剖。
- 临床与影像报告应避免仅凭影像诊断II型食管裂孔疝。
- 关注并参与食管裂孔疝分类系统的修订讨论。
局限性
- 研究为单中心回顾性复习,证据来源限于本院病例、公开手术视频与会议摘要。
- 网站视频仅发现1例可能的II型疝,无法完全排除其存在。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Type II hiatal hernias (HH) are characterized by a portion of the gastric fundus located above the esophageal hiatus adjacent to the esophagus while the gastroesophageal junction (GEJ) remains fixed below the esophageal hiatus. This type of HH has been called the "true" paraesophageal hernia (PEH) because the fundus appears to the side of the esophagus. In our experience, Type II HHs are occasionally identified on radiographic testing, however they are rarely, if ever, confirmed intraoperatively. This led to our question: Does Type II HH exist? METHODS: We searched for evidence of type II HH in three locations: 1. Retrospective review of all first-time PEH repairs (excluding Type I HHs and re-operative cases) performed at the University of Washington Medical Center from 1994 to 2021; 2. Operative videos available on YouTube and WebSurg websites; and 3. Abstracts from the SAGES annual meetings from 2005 to 2021. RESULTS: We found no evidence of Type II HH in any of our three searches. We performed 846 PEH repairs: 760 Type III, 75 Type IV, and 11 parahiatal. Upon website video review, we found only one possible type II hernia, though it too was likely a para-hiatal hernia. No video or case presentations of a type II HH were identified within SAGES annual meeting abstracts. CONCLUSION: Type II HHs do not exist as they are currently defined. Although uncommon, parahiatal hernia can easily be misinterpreted as Type II HH. We should consider changing the hiatal hernia classification system to prevent ongoing clinical confusion.
引用
- Ceron REC, Yates RB, Wright AS, et al. Type II hiatal hernias: do they exist or are they actually parahiatal hernias? Surg Endosc. 2022. PMID: 36261642. doi:10.1007/s00464-022-09641-9
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。