指南与共识甲状腺与颈部外科

治疗结果对外科医生低风险甲状腺癌推荐方案的相对重要性

The relative importance of treatment outcomes to surgeons' recommendations for low-risk thyroid cancer.
指南 / 共识 · Surgery · 2022-09-29

该横断面调查评估了甲状腺外科医生对低风险甲状腺癌治疗结果的重视程度如何影响其推荐。165名受访者中35.8%推荐全甲状腺切除,64.2%推荐腺叶切除。两组对10项治疗结果的重要性评分存在显著差异(P < .05):推荐全切者最重视复发风险(19.1分),推荐腺叶切除者最重视激素替代需求(14.3分)。

要点

  • 推荐全甲状腺切除的医生更重视复发风险,评分是推荐腺叶切除者的1.6倍。
  • 推荐腺叶切除的医生更重视激素替代需求,评分是推荐全切者的3.1倍。
  • 医生对治疗结果的不同优先排序影响其手术推荐,需关注患者价值观的匹配。

核心结论

  • 推荐全甲状腺切除与推荐腺叶切除的外科医生对癌症复发和甲状腺激素替代的重要性排序不同,理解医生信念对推荐的影响有助于使患者治疗与其价值观一致。

研究设计与样本

  • 横断面调查,纳入165名甲状腺外科医生(应答率74.3%),针对一名健康45岁、单发、低风险、2厘米乳头状甲状腺癌患者询问治疗推荐,并使用恒定总和量表(100分分配于10项治疗结果)评估重要性。

主要发现

  • 165名受访者中35.8%(n=59)推荐全甲状腺切除,64.2%(n=106)推荐腺叶切除。
  • 两组对10项治疗结果的重要性评分存在显著差异(P < .05)。
  • 推荐全甲状腺切除者最受复发风险影响(19.1分,标准差16.5),将其重要性评为推荐腺叶切除者的1.6倍。
  • 推荐腺叶切除者高度重视激素替代需求(14.3分,标准差15.4),将其重要性评为推荐全甲状腺切除者的3.1倍。

临床怎么用

  • 面对低风险甲状腺癌患者时,外科医生应意识到自身对复发与激素替代的优先排序可能影响推荐,并促进与患者价值观一致的决策。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: The treatment of low-risk thyroid cancer is controversial. We evaluated the importance of treatment outcomes to surgeons' recommendations. METHODS: A cross-sectional survey asked thyroid surgeons for their treatment recommendations for a healthy 45-year-old patient with a solitary, low-risk, 2-cm papillary thyroid cancer. The importance of the 10 treatment outcomes (survival, recurrence, etc.) to their recommendation was evaluated using constant sum scaling, a method where 100 points are allocated among the treatment outcomes; more points indicate higher importance. The distribution of points was compared between surgeons recommending total thyroidectomy and surgeons recommending lobectomy using Hottelling's T2 test. RESULTS: Of 165 respondents (74.3% response rate), 35.8% (n = 59) recommended total thyroidectomy and 64.2% (n = 106) lobectomy. The importance of the 10 treatment outcomes was significantly different between groups (P < .05). Surgeons recommending total thyroidectomy were most influenced by the risk of recurrence (19.1 points; standard deviation 16.5) and rated this 1.6-times more important than those recommending lobectomy. Conversely, surgeons recommending lobectomy placed high emphasis on need for hormone replacement (14.3 points; standard deviation 15.4), rating this 3.1-times more important than those recommending total thyroidectomy. CONCLUSION: Surgeons who recommend total thyroidectomy and those who recommend lobectomy differently prioritize the importance of cancer recurrence and thyroid hormone replacement. Understanding how surgeons' beliefs influence their recommendations is important for ensuring patients receive treatment aligned with their values.

来源:Surgery,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Chiu AS, Saucke MC, Bushaw K, et al. The relative importance of treatment outcomes to surgeons' recommendations for low-risk thyroid cancer. Surgery. 2022. PMID: 36182602. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2022.05.002

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。