腹腔镜与开腹胰十二指肠切除术的试验序贯Meta分析:是时候停止随机化了吗?
该研究对4项比较腹腔镜胰十二指肠切除术(LPD)与开腹胰十二指肠切除术(OPD)的随机对照试验(共818例患者)进行Meta分析,并采用试验序贯分析检验I类和II类错误。结果显示两组在死亡率、主要并发症和术后胰瘘上无显著差异,但所需信息量(RIS)远超现有样本,提示等效性结论受II类错误影响;LPD手术时间显著更长,住院时间显著更短。
要点
- LPD与OPD在死亡率、主要并发症和POPF上无显著差异,但RIS远超现有样本量。
- LPD手术时间较OPD显著延长(MD 63.22),住院时间显著缩短(MD -1.76天)。
- 其余终点无显著差异,需超过3000例患者才能确认等效性。
核心结论
- LPD与OPD在死亡率、主要并发症和POPF上的等效性受II类错误影响。
- 证明任一技术优越性的所需信息量似乎不现实。
研究设计与样本
- 对比较LPD与OPD的随机研究进行Meta分析,共纳入4项RCT、818例患者。
- 采用试验序贯分析检验I类和II类错误并定义所需信息量(RIS)。
主要发现
- 死亡率RR为1.16,主要并发症RR为1.04,POPF RR为0.86,均无显著差异。
- 死亡率、主要并发症和POPF的RIS分别为35672、16548和8206;确认等效性至少需随机化34854、15730和7338例。
- LPD手术时间显著长于OPD,MD为63.22;住院时间显著短于OPD,MD为-1.76天。
- 手术时间和住院时间的RIS分别为1297和1273,排除了假阳性结果。
- 其余终点无显著差异,RIS提示需随机化超过3000例患者以确认等效性。
关键数值与推荐
- 死亡率RR 1.16(无显著差异),RIS 35672,需随机化至少34854例。
- 主要并发症RR 1.04(无显著差异),RIS 16548,需随机化至少15730例。
- POPF RR 0.86(无显著差异),RIS 8206,需随机化至少7338例。
- 手术时间MD 63.22(LPD更长),RIS 1297;住院时间MD -1.76天(LPD更短),RIS 1273。
临床怎么用
- 现有证据不足以宣称LPD与OPD在死亡率、主要并发症和POPF上等效。
- LPD手术时间更长但住院时间更短,临床决策需权衡这些差异。
- 进一步随机化以证明等效性或优越性所需样本量巨大,可能不现实。
局限性
- 仅纳入4项RCT、818例患者,样本量远低于RIS。
- 等效性结论受II类错误影响。
- 证明任一技术优越性的所需信息量似乎不现实。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The advantages of LPD compared with OPD remain debatable. The study aimed to compare the laparoscopic (LPD) versus open (OPD) for pancreaticoduodenectomy. METHODS: A meta-analysis of randomized studies (RCTs) comparing LPD and OPD was made. The results were reported as relative risk (RRs) or mean differences (MDs). The trial sequential analysis was used to test the type I and type II errors defining the required information size (RIS). The primary outcome was mortality, major morbidity, and postoperative pancreatic fistula (POPF). R1 resection, post-pancreatectomy hemorrhage, delayed gastric emptying, biliary fistula, reoperation, readmission, operative time (OT), lymph nodes harvested, and length of stay (LOS) were also studied. RESULTS: Four RCTs, counting 818 patients, were found. The RRs for mortality, major morbidity, and POPF were 1.16, 1.04, and 0.86, without significant differences. The RISs were 35,672, 16,548, and 8206. To confirm this equivalence, at least 34,854, 15,730, and 7338 should be randomized. OT was significantly longer in LPD than OPD, with an MD of 63.22. The LOS was significantly shorter in LPD than in OPD, with - 1.76 days. The RISs were 1297 and 1273, excluding a false-positive result. No significant differences were observed for the remaining endpoints, and RISs suggested that more than 3000 patients should be randomized to confirm the equivalence. CONCLUSION: The equivalence of LPD and OPD for mortality, major morbidity, and POPF is affected by type II error. The RISs to demonstrate a superiority of one of the two techniques seem unrealistic to obtain.
引用
- Ricci C, Stocco A, Ingaldi C, et al. Trial sequential meta-analysis of laparoscopic versus open pancreaticoduodenectomy: is it the time to stop the randomization? Surg Endosc. 2022. PMID: 36253625. doi:10.1007/s00464-022-09660-6
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。