手术室中的干扰因素:医疗团队认知调查
本研究通过26题问卷调查了160名外科医生、麻醉人员及手术室护士对手术室多种干扰因素的感知与排序。结果显示听觉干扰和设备类干扰最突出,电话/寻呼机及病例相关沟通是最常见干扰源;病例相关沟通、音乐、教学和会诊被认为对手术流程有正面影响。
要点
- 听觉干扰和设备是手术室最主要的干扰因素。
- 电话/寻呼机及病例相关沟通是最常见干扰源。
- 病例相关沟通、音乐、教学和会诊被认为有正面影响。
核心结论
- 听觉干扰和设备类干扰是手术室中最突出的干扰因素。
- 电话/寻呼机及病例相关沟通是最常见的干扰源。
- 病例相关沟通、音乐、教学和会诊被认为对手术流程有正面影响。
研究设计与样本
- 对一家机构的外科医生、麻醉团队成员、护士和擦洗技师进行26题问卷调查。
- 共160名应答者,应答率19.18%(160/834)。
- 应答者中男性71名(44.1%),女性82名(50.9%)。
- 外科医生48名(29.8%),麻醉医生/注册护士麻醉师59名(36.6%),手术室护士和擦洗技师53名(32.9%)。
- 应答者按经验分为初级组(<10年)和高级组(≥10年)。
主要发现
- 听觉干扰和设备是手术室中最主要的干扰因素。
- 除音乐外,调查中所有潜在听觉干扰均与对手术流程一定程度的负面影响的更高百分比相关。
- 排名前5的干扰因素属于设备和环境类别。
- 电话/寻呼机/传呼机和病例相关沟通始终位列最常见干扰因素前5名。
- 病例相关沟通、音乐、教学和会诊是对手术流程正面影响感知最强的前4项。
临床怎么用
- 减少不必要的干扰可能改善手术流程、提升手术室团队合作并可能改善患者结局。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Distractions during surgical procedures are associated with team inefficiency and medical error. Little is published about the healthcare provider's perception of distraction and its adverse impact in the operating room. We aim to explore the perception of the operating room team on multiple distractions during surgical procedures. METHODS: A 26-question survey was administered to surgeons, anesthesia team members, nurses, and scrub technicians at our institution. Respondents were asked to identify and rank multiple distractions and indicate how each distraction might affect the flow of surgery. RESULTS: There was 160 responders for a response rate of 19.18% (160/834), of which 71 (44.1%) male and 82 (50.9%) female, 48 (29.8%) surgeons, 59 (36.6%) anesthesiologists, Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetists (CRNA), and 53 (32.9%) OR nurses and scrub technicians. Responders were classified into a junior group (< 10 years of experience) and a senior group (≥ 10 years). Auditory distraction followed by equipment were the most distracting factors in the operating room. All potential auditory distractions in this survey were associated with higher percentage of certain level of negative impact on the flow of surgery except for music. The top 5 distractors belonged to equipment and environment categories. Phone calls/ pagers/ beepers and case relevant communications were consistently among the top 5 most common distractors. Case relevant communications, music, teaching, and consultation were the top 4 most perceived positive impact on the flow of surgery. Distractors with higher levels of "bothersome" rating appeared to associate with a higher level of perceived negative impact on the flow of surgery. Vision was the least distracting factor and appeared to cause minimal positive impact on the flow of surgery. CONCLUSIONS: To our knowledge, this is the first survey studying perception of surgery, anesthesia, and OR staff on various distractions in the operating room. Fewer unnecessary distractions might improve the flow of surgery, improve OR teamwork, and potentially improve patient outcomes.
引用
- Nasri BN, Mitchell JD, Jackson C, et al. Distractions in the operating room: a survey of the healthcare team. Surg Endosc. 2022. PMID: 36070145. doi:10.1007/s00464-022-09553-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。