围术期护理集束化措施预防手术部位感染的Meta分析
该Meta分析纳入4项RCT、1项对照前后研究和13项中断时间序列研究,评估含至少一项术中干预的护理集束化措施预防手术部位感染的效果。中断时间序列Meta分析显示感染率水平变化为-1.16(95%CI -1.78至-0.53),提示感染减少;RCT汇总数据异质性大,集束化措施中循证干预比例较高时效果可能更大。
要点
- 围术期护理集束化措施可减少手术部位感染,中断时间序列Meta分析显示水平变化-1.16。
- RCT汇总数据异质性大,效果不一致。
- 集束化措施包含较高比例循证干预时效果可能更大,但未发现有效特征的强证据。
核心结论
- 中断时间序列Meta分析表明围术期护理集束化措施可预防手术部位感染。
- 该效果在RCT间不一致。
- 较大的集束化措施与更大效果无关,但若包含高比例循证干预则效果可能更大。
- 未识别出有效集束化措施特征的强证据。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述、再分析和Meta分析,纳入RCT、对照前后研究及可再分析为中断时间序列研究的非对照前后研究。
- 共纳入4项RCT、1项对照前后研究和13项中断时间序列研究。
- 纳入研究调查含至少一项术中干预的护理集束化措施与标准护理的比较。
主要发现
- RCT汇总数据存在异质性。
- 中断时间序列Meta分析显示水平变化为-1.16(95%CI -1.78至-0.53),表明手术部位感染减少。
- 当集束化措施包含较高比例循证干预时效果更大。
- Meta回归分析未显示效果估计与干预数量、循证干预数量或循证干预比例之间有统计学显著关联。
临床怎么用
- 围术期可考虑使用护理集束化措施预防手术部位感染。
- 集束化措施中应优先纳入循证干预,而非单纯增加干预数量。
局限性
- RCT汇总数据异质性大,效果不一致。
- 未识别出有效集束化措施特征的强证据。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Care bundles are used widely to prevent surgical-site infections (SSIs). Recent systematic reviews suggested larger effects from bundles with more interventions. These reviews were largely based on uncontrolled before-after studies and did not consider their biases. The aim of this meta-analysis was to determine the effectiveness of care bundles to prevent SSIs and explore characteristics of effective care bundles. METHODS: A systematic review, reanalysis, and meta-analysis of available evidence were undertaken. RCTs, controlled before-after studies, and uncontrolled before-after studies with sufficient data for reanalysis as interrupted time series studies (ITS) were eligible. Studies investigating the use of a care bundle, with at least one intraoperative intervention, compared with standard care were included. RESULTS: Four RCTs, 1 controlled before-after study, and 13 ITS were included. Pooled data from RCTs were heterogeneous. Meta-analysis of ITS resulted in a level change of -1.16 (95 per cent c.i.-1.78 to -0.53), indicating a reduction in SSI. The effect was larger when the care bundle comprised a higher proportion of evidence-based interventions. Meta-regression analyses did not show statistically significant associations between effect estimates and number of interventions, number of evidence-based interventions, or proportion of evidence-based interventions. CONCLUSION: Meta-analysis of ITS indicated that perioperative care bundles prevent SSI. This effect is inconsistent across RCTs. Larger bundles were not associated with a larger effect, but the effect may be larger if the care bundle contains a high proportion of evidence-based interventions. No strong evidence for characteristics of effective care bundles was identified.
引用
- Wolfhagen N, Boldingh QJJ, Boermeester MA, et al. Perioperative care bundles for the prevention of surgical-site infections: meta-analysis. Br J Surg. 2022. PMID: 35766252. doi:10.1093/bjs/znac196
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。