结直肠手术后异步远程医疗与面诊的效果与满意度比较
这项前瞻性单臂队列研究在单中心纳入33例腹部结直肠手术患者,术前48小时通过网页问卷提交资料和切口照片,医生24小时内回复,随后面诊对比。结果显示医生认为线上问卷与面诊一致率达90%,但仅半数患者认为单纯线上问卷可接受随访;线上面诊显著节省时间,面诊中4例(13.3%)调整了管理方案。
要点
- 医生认为线上问卷与面诊一致率达90%,但仅半数患者接受单纯线上随访。
- 线上问卷完成时间≤10分钟,显著短于面诊(含交通)的75分钟(IQR 50-100)。
- 仅12例(40%)上传切口照片,面诊中4例(13.3%)调整管理,其中3例治疗浅表手术部位感染(10%)。
核心结论
- 异步网页随访形式对结直肠外科医生可接受,但仅半数患者接受,尽管显著节省时间;患者更偏好面诊,可通过患者选择和教育扩大远程医疗接受度。
研究设计与样本
- 前瞻性单臂队列研究,单三级中心,纳入33例腹部结直肠手术患者,术前48小时完成网页问卷并上传切口照片,医生24小时内回复,随后面诊对比。
主要发现
- 33例中30例(90.9%)成功完成网页问卷。
- 医生报告线上问卷与面诊一致率为90%。
- 完成研究的患者中仅半数认为单纯问卷可接受随访。
- 患者完成线上问卷时间≤10分钟,显著少于面诊含交通时间的75分钟(IQR 50-100)。
- 仅12例(40%)上传切口照片;面诊中4例(13.3%)调整管理,其中3例(10%)需治疗浅表手术部位感染。
临床怎么用
- 结直肠术后随访可尝试异步网页问卷作为面诊的补充,但需注意仅半数患者接受且切口照片上传率低(40%),应加强患者选择和教育。
局限性
- 单中心、单臂、样本量小(33例),未设对照组,患者满意度和医生一致性评估可能受限于研究设计。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The feasibility of remote visits following abdominal colorectal surgery has not been studied in relation to efficacy, patient satisfaction, and surgeon satisfaction. This study aims to assess reliability and satisfaction with a web-based questionnaire for post-operative visits following abdominal colorectal surgery. METHODS: This was a prospective single-arm cohort study at single-tertiary care center during admission for abdominal colorectal surgery. Using a web-based patient portal, patients completed a questionnaire 48 h prior to their scheduled in-person follow-up visits and submitted photographs of their incisions. Surgeons reviewed patient-entered data and responded within 24 h. Following the subsequent in-person visit, surgeons completed questionnaires to compare the accuracy of the web-based vs. in-person evaluations. Lastly, patients and surgeons completed separate satisfaction surveys after the in-person visits. RESULTS: A total of 33 patients were enrolled, of which 30 (90.9%) successfully completed the web questionnaire. Providers reported the online questionnaire to be concordant with the in-person visit in 90% of cases. Of the patients who completed the study, only half found the survey alone to be acceptable for follow-up. Patients spent significantly less time completing the online questionnaire (≤ 10 min) than in-person visits, including travel time (75 min, IQR 50-100). Only 12 patients (40%) uploaded photographs of their incisions. During in-person visits, management changes were employed in four patients (13.3%), of which 3 required treatment of superficial surgical site infections (10%). CONCLUSION: This asynchronous web-based visit format was acceptable to colorectal surgeons but was only embraced by half of patients, despite considerable time savings. While patients preferred in-person visits, there may be opportunities to expand TeleHealth acceptance that focus on patient selection and education. CLINICALTRIALS: gov: NCT05084131.
引用
- Beauharnais CC, Hill SS, Sturrock PR, et al. Efficacy and satisfaction of asynchronous TeleHealth care compared to in-person visits following colorectal surgical resection. Surg Endosc. 2022. PMID: 35713720. doi:10.1007/s00464-022-09383-8
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。