阑尾炎分类争议与术后抗生素使用
该调查研究了外科医生和外科受训者对阑尾炎术中分类的评分者间一致性及其对术后抗生素处方的影响。共562名受访者完成调查,分类一致性在坏疽/穿孔与非坏疽/非穿孔之间最高(Krippendorff's alpha=0.73),在穿孔与非穿孔之间最低(Krippendorff's alpha=0.45);术后抗生素使用的一致性低(Krippendorff's alpha=0.28)。作者认为需要进一步共识以标准化研究并避免不必要的抗生素过度治疗。
要点
- 阑尾炎术中分类的评分者间一致性差,穿孔与非穿孔之间最低(Krippendorff's alpha=0.45)。
- 术后抗生素使用一致性低(Krippendorff's alpha=0.28),处方比例随病情严重程度升高。
- 作者报告59%的医生在非坏疽或非穿孔阑尾切除术后仍处方抗生素。
核心结论
- 外科医生对主观阑尾炎分类和客观术后抗生素使用的一致性均差。
- 该调查显示大部分(59%)外科医生在非坏疽或非穿孔阑尾切除术后处方抗生素,尽管缺乏证据基础。
- 作者认为这些发现凸显需要进一步共识以支持标准化研究并避免不必要的抗生素过度治疗。
研究设计与样本
- 调查包含15张阑尾切除术中捕获的术中图像,分发给外科医生和外科受训者。
- 共562名受访者完成调查:206名外科受训者、217名成人外科医生和139名小儿外科医生。
- 参与者被要求对疾病严重程度进行分类(正常、炎症、化脓、坏疽、穿孔)并说明是否会处方术后抗生素。
- 统计分析包括百分比一致性、Krippendorff's alpha评分者间一致性和逻辑回归。
主要发现
- 对于阑尾炎分类,评分者间一致性最高为坏疽/穿孔与非坏疽/非穿孔分类(Krippendorff's alpha=0.73),最低为穿孔与非穿孔分类(Krippendorff's alpha=0.45)。
- 14%的受访者会为炎症阑尾处方术后抗生素,44%为化脓性,75%为坏疽性,97%为穿孔性阑尾炎。
- 术后抗生素使用的评分者间一致性低(Krippendorff's alpha=0.28)。
- 与术后抗生素使用相关的唯一显著因素是执业16年或以上。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is wide variability and considerable controversy regarding the classification of appendicitis and the need for postoperative antibiotics. This study aimed to assess interrater agreement with respect to the classification of appendicitis and its influence on the use of postoperative antibiotics amongst surgeons and surgical trainees. METHODS: A survey comprising 15 intraoperative images captured during appendectomy was distributed to surgeons and surgical trainees. Participants were asked to classify severity of disease (normal, inflamed, purulent, gangrenous, perforated) and whether they would prescribe postoperative antibiotics. Statistical analysis included percent agreement, Krippendorff's alpha for interrater agreement, and logistic regression. RESULTS: In total, 562 respondents completed the survey: 206 surgical trainees, 217 adult surgeons, and 139 pediatric surgeons. For classification of appendicitis, the statistical interrater agreement was highest for categorization as gangrenous/perforated versus nongangrenous/nonperforated (Krippendorff's alpha = 0.73) and lowest for perforated versus nonperforated (Krippendorff's alpha = 0.45). Fourteen percent of survey respondents would administer postoperative antibiotics for an inflamed appendix, 44% for suppurative, 75% for gangrenous, and 97% for perforated appendicitis. Interrater agreement of postoperative antibiotic use was low (Krippendorff's alpha = 0.28). The only significant factor associated with postoperative antibiotic utilization was 16 or more years in practice. CONCLUSIONS: Surgeon agreement is poor with respect to both subjective appendicitis classification and objective utilization of postoperative antibiotics. This survey demonstrates that a large proportion (59%) of surgeons prescribe antibiotics after nongangrenous or nonperforated appendectomy, despite a lack of evidence basis for this practice. These findings highlight the need for further consensus to enable standardized research and avoid overtreatment with unnecessary antibiotics.
引用
- Buonpane CL, Vacek J, Harris CJ, et al. Controversy in the classification of appendicitis and utilization of postoperative antibiotics. Surgery. 2021. PMID: 34774292. doi:10.1016/j.surg.2021.10.006
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。