全科医生关于老年多病共存患者减停降压药的心智线条:英国全科实践质性研究
本研究采用质性访谈方法,纳入英格兰东部7家全科诊所的15名全科医生,借助图表刺激回忆法探讨其对80岁及以上多病共存高血压患者减停降压药的决策过程。研究发现,当出现跌倒或药物不良事件等触发因素时,全科医生通常有信心减停降压药;而对多药共存的一般性担忧则信心不足,需综合证据、共享经验与非临床因素形成「心智线条」来指导决策。
要点
- 跌倒或药物不良事件等触发因素可增强全科医生减停降压药的信心。
- 对多药共存的一般性担忧不足以让全科医生自信地尝试减停降压药。
- 全科医生通过临床经验形成「心智线条」以应对减停决策的不确定性。
核心结论
- 在缺乏明确证据指导多药共存担忧下何时及如何减药时,全科医生通过基于实践的经验逐渐形成「心智线条」以做出复杂决策。
研究设计与样本
- 质性访谈研究,采用主题分析,样本为英格兰东部7家全科诊所的15名全科医生,使用图表刺激回忆法。
主要发现
- 全科医生在跌倒或药物不良事件等触发因素提示时,通常有信心为80岁及以上多病共存患者减停降压药。
- 全科医生对仅因多药共存的一般性担忧而尝试减停降压药信心较低。
- 全科医生努力综合可用证据、共享经验知识及非临床因素等多来源信息来指导决策。
临床怎么用
- 全科医生可借助跌倒或药物不良事件等触发因素启动老年多病共存患者的降压药减停讨论。
- 面对多药共存担忧时,可通过反思性实践强化「心智线条」以提升减停决策信心。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Optimal management of hypertension in older patients with multimorbidity is a cornerstone of primary care practice. Despite emphasis on personalised approaches to treatment in older patients, there is little guidance on how to achieve medication reduction when GPs are concerned that possible risks outweigh potential benefits of treatment. Mindlines - tacit, internalised guidelines developed over time from multiple sources - may be of particular importance in such situations. AIM: To explore GPs' decision-making on deprescribing antihypertensives in patients with multimorbidity aged ≥80 years, drawing on the concept of mindlines. DESIGN AND SETTING: Qualitative interview study set in English general practice. METHOD: Thematic analysis of face-to-face interviews with a sample of 15 GPs from seven practices in the East of England, using a chart-stimulated recall approach to explore approaches to treatment for older patients with multimorbidity with hypertension. RESULTS: GPs are typically confident making decisions to deprescribe antihypertensive medication in older patients with multimorbidity when prompted by a trigger, such as a fall or adverse drug event. GPs are less confident to attempt deprescribing in response to generalised concerns about polypharmacy, and work hard to make sense of multiple sources (including available evidence, shared experiential knowledge, and non-clinical factors) to guide decision-making. CONCLUSION: In the absence of a clear evidence base on when and how to attempt medication reduction in response to concerns about polypharmacy, GPs develop 'mindlines' over time through practicebased experience. These tacit approaches to making complex decisions are critical to developing confidence to attempt deprescribing and may be strengthened through reflective practice.
引用
- Kuberska K, Scheibl F, Sinnott C, et al. GPs' mindlines on deprescribing antihypertensives in older patients with multimorbidity: a qualitative study in English general practice. Br J Gen Pract. 2021. PMID: 34001537. doi:10.3399/bjgp21X714305
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。