临终诊断的差异:对衰弱老年人社区医疗提供者的定性访谈
本研究通过定性访谈19名社区医疗提供者,探讨临终诊断在塑造院外医疗中的角色。参与者认为将衰弱老年人视为临终诊断候选人不寻常且有问题,但该诊断有助于优先照护并提供额外服务。结论指出临终诊断是获得社区照护的「头等票」,无此诊断者可能在照护提供方面处于劣势。
要点
- 临终诊断有助于提供者优先照护并增加服务,但衰弱老年人常不被视为诊断候选人。
- 无临终诊断的衰弱老年人可能在社区照护中获得较少优先权和额外服务。
- 识别这一不平等应帮助决策者和从业者缓解其影响。
核心结论
- 临终诊断是获得社区照护的「头等票」,无此诊断者可能在照护提供方面处于劣势。
研究设计与样本
- 对19名来自社区医疗场所(包括养老院和非工作时间服务)的医疗提供者进行半结构化访谈(9次个人访谈,3次小组访谈)。
- 数据采用主题分析和持续比较法进行分析。
主要发现
- 参与者认为将衰弱老年人视为临终诊断候选人不寻常且有问题。
- 参与者认为临终诊断对提供者有用,有助于优先照护被诊断为临终的人并提供额外服务。
- 这种优先和额外帮助被识别为排除了没有临终诊断而死亡的人。
临床怎么用
- 社区医疗提供者应意识到无临终诊断的衰弱老年人可能在照护优先权和额外服务方面处于劣势。
- 决策者和从业者可基于此认识采取措施缓解该不平等。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Increasing numbers of people die of the frailty and multimorbidity associated with old age, often without receiving an end-of-life diagnosis. Compared to those with a single life-limiting condition such as cancer, frail older people are less likely to access adequate community care. To address this inequality, guidance for professional providers of community health care encourages them to make end-of-life diagnoses more often in such people. These diagnoses centre on prognosis, making them difficult to establish given the inherent unpredictability of age-related decline. This difficulty makes it important to ask how care provision is affected by not having an end-of-life diagnosis. AIM: To explore the role of an end-of-life diagnosis in shaping the provision of health care outside acute hospitals. DESIGN AND SETTING: Qualitative interviews with 19 healthcare providers from community-based settings, including nursing homes and out-of-hours services. METHOD: Semi-structured interviews (nine individual, three small group) were conducted. Data were analysed thematically and using constant comparison. RESULTS: In the participants' accounts, it was unusual and problematic to consider frail older people as candidates for end-of-life diagnosis. Participants talked of this diagnosis as being useful to them as care providers, helping them prioritise caring for people diagnosed as 'end-of-life' and enabling them to offer additional services. This prioritisation and additional help was identified as excluding people who die without an end-of-life diagnosis. CONCLUSION: End-of-life diagnosis is a first-class ticket to community care; people who die without such a diagnosis are potentially disadvantaged as regards care provision. Recognising this inequity should help policymakers and practitioners to mitigate it.
引用
- Polak L, Hopkins S, Barclay S, et al. The difference an end-of-life diagnosis makes: qualitative interviews with providers of community health care for frail older people. Br J Gen Pract. 2020. PMID: 32958536. doi:10.3399/bjgp20X712805
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。