全科医生教育干预改善儿童急性中耳炎疼痛管理:整群随机对照试验
该整群随机对照试验纳入荷兰37家全科诊所的224名全科医生确诊的急性中耳炎伴耳痛患儿,评估针对全科医生的教育干预(培训讨论疼痛管理并提供信息传单、按体重处方对乙酰氨基酚、必要时加用布洛芬)的效果。结果显示干预组与对照组前3天平均耳痛评分相似,但干预组镇痛药使用(尤其布洛芬)增加,抗生素处方总数相似,而干预组家长因中耳炎相关主诉再咨询率更高。结论提示该干预增加镇痛药使用但无临床症状获益,全科医生应权衡布洛芬的潜在获益与可能危害。
要点
- 全科医生教育干预未降低急性中耳炎患儿前3天耳痛评分。
- 干预组镇痛药使用增加,尤其布洛芬,但抗生素处方总数无差异。
- 干预组家长因中耳炎相关主诉再咨询率更高,需权衡布洛芬获益与危害。
核心结论
- 旨在改善急性中耳炎疼痛管理的全科医生教育干预增加镇痛药使用(尤其布洛芬),但未提供症状获益。
- 全科医生应仔细权衡布洛芬的潜在获益与可能危害。
研究设计与样本
- 实用性整群随机对照试验,荷兰37家全科诊所(干预组19家,对照组18家)。
- 纳入224名全科医生确诊的急性中耳炎伴耳痛患儿(干预组94名,对照组130名),招募时间2015年2月至2018年5月。
- 干预组全科医生接受在线和面对面培训,使用信息传单与家长讨论疼痛管理,并被提示处方按体重计算剂量的对乙酰氨基酚;若疼痛控制仍不充分,额外处方布洛芬。对照组提供常规 care。
主要发现
- 前3天平均耳痛评分两组相似(4.66 vs 4.36;校正均数差=-0.05;95%CI=-0.93至0.83)。
- 干预组镇痛药使用更高,尤其布洛芬。
- 28天随访期间抗生素处方总数相似(平均率0.43 vs 0.47;校正率比[aRR]=0.97;95%CI=0.68至1.38)。
- 干预组家长更可能因中耳炎相关主诉再咨询(平均率0.70 vs 0.41;aRR=1.73;95%CI=1.14至2.62)。
临床怎么用
- 全科医生应谨慎权衡布洛芬用于急性中耳炎患儿的潜在获益与可能危害。
- 教育干预虽增加镇痛药使用,但未改善耳痛评分,且与再咨询率升高相关。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Pain management in acute otitis media (AOM) is often suboptimal, potentially leading to unnecessary discomfort, GP reconsultation, and antibiotic prescribing. AIM: To assess the effectiveness of a GP-targeted educational intervention to improve pain management in children with AOM. DESIGN AND SETTING: Pragmatic, cluster randomised controlled trial (RCT). GPs in 37 practices (intervention n = 19; control n = 18) across the Netherlands recruited 224 children with GP-confirmed AOM and ear pain (intervention n = 94; control n = 130) between February 2015 and May 2018. METHOD: GPs in practices allocated to the intervention group were trained (online and face-to-face) to discuss pain management with parents using an information leaflet, and prompted to prescribe weight-appropriate dosed paracetamol. Ibuprofen was additionally prescribed if pain control was still insufficient. GPs in the control group provided usual care. RESULTS: Mean ear pain scores over the first 3 days were similar between groups (4.66 versus 4.36; adjusted mean difference = -0.05; 95% confidence intervals [CI] = -0.93 to 0.83), whereas analgesic use, in particular ibuprofen, was higher in the intervention group. The total number of antibiotic prescriptions during the 28-day follow-up was similar (mean rate 0.43 versus 0.47; adjusted rate ratio [aRR] 0.97; 95% CI = 0.68 to 1.38). Parents of children in the intervention group were more likely to reconsult for AOM-related complaints (mean rate 0.70 versus 0.41; aRR 1.73; 95% CI = 1.14 to 2.62). CONCLUSION: An intervention aimed at improving pain management for AOM increases analgesic use, particularly ibuprofen, but does not provide symptomatic benefit. GPs are advised to carefully weigh the potential benefits of ibuprofen against its possible harms.
引用
- van Uum RT, Venekamp RP, Zuithoff NP, et al. Improving pain management in childhood acute otitis media in general practice: a cluster randomised controlled trial of a GP-targeted educational intervention. Br J Gen Pract. 2020. PMID: 32839161. doi:10.3399/bjgp20X712589
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。