马里与法国全科医生管理健康问题范围比较:撒哈拉以南非洲实践转型初现
BACKGROUND: Minimal data are available on the clinical activity of general practitioners (GPs) in Africa. OBJECTIVE: To describe the health problems managed by GPs in Mali as compared with France where epidemiological transition is already advanced.…
要点
- 马里全科医生管理感染占51.3%,其中疟疾24.9%、肺炎9.0%、胃肠道感染5.0%。
- 马里慢性病管理占12.3%,远低于法国39.6%;高血压占马里管理问题的18.9%。
- 法国全科医生预防活动占11.0%,在马里几乎可忽略。
核心结论
- 非洲正处流行病学转型交叉点,慢性病负担上升而传染病负担仍沉重,马里初级保健实践转型初现。
研究设计与样本
- 回顾性多中心研究,比较马里5个社区卫生中心与法国ECOGEN研究128家全科诊所的咨询数据,经年龄性别标准化。
主要发现
- 马里每次咨询平均管理1.2个健康问题,法国为2.2个。
- 马里以感染为主占51.3%,包括疟疾24.9%、肺炎9.0%、胃肠道感染5.0%。
- 马里全科医生较法国更常管理心血管问题(20.2%对13.5%)、呼吸系统问题(15.0%对12.4%)和消化系统问题(13.3%对7.8%)。
- 马里全科医生较法国更少管理肌肉骨骼问题(3.1%对12.6%)、内分泌/代谢问题(1.5%对10.7%)和心理问题(0.2%对8.2%)。
- 除高血压(占马里管理问题的18.9%)外,马里慢性病管理频率低于法国(12.3%对39.6%)。
临床怎么用
- 在撒哈拉以南非洲基层应同时强化传染病诊治能力与逐步发展慢性病管理。
- 马里初级保健需提升医疗化程度以应对正在出现的实践转型。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Minimal data are available on the clinical activity of general practitioners (GPs) in Africa. OBJECTIVE: To describe the health problems managed by GPs in Mali as compared with France where epidemiological transition is already advanced. METHODS: A retrospective, multicenter study, conducted in five Malian Community Health Centers. We compared their consultation data to those of the ECOGEN (Eléments de la COnsultation en médecine GENérale) study conducted in 128 French general practices, after data standardization for age and sex. RESULTS: Malian and French databases included 19 068 and 19 341 consultations, respectively. Patients had an average of 1.2 health problems managed per consultation in Mali, versus 2.2 in France. They were dominated by infections (51.3%) in Mali, including malaria (24.9%), pneumonia (9.0%) and gastrointestinal infections (5.0%). In comparison with French GPs, Malian GPs more frequently managed cardiovascular (20.2% versus 13.5%), respiratory (15.0% versus 12.4%) and digestive (13.3% versus 7.8%) problems, and less frequently musculoskeletal (3.1% versus 12.6%), endocrine/metabolic (1.5% versus 10.7%) and psychological (0.2% versus 8.2%) problems. The main activity performed by French GPs was prevention (11.0%), which was nominal in Mali. Apart from hypertension, which accounted for 18.9% of the health problems managed in Mali, chronic conditions were less often managed by Malian GPs than by French GPs (12.3% versus 39.6%). CONCLUSIONS: Africa is currently at the crossroads where chronic conditions carried with the epidemiological transition are progressing, while the burden of communicable diseases is still overwhelming. Along with the enhancing medicalization of primary care in Mali, the transition of practices is just emerging.
引用
- Naville R, Subtil F, Sy M, et al. Scope of health problems managed by general practitioners in Mali and France: awaiting practice transition in sub-Saharan Africa? Fam Pract. 2020. PMID: 32531028. doi:10.1093/fampra/cmaa035
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。