影响临床预防指南更新采纳的因素:一项定性研究
该定性研究于2018年对多元化的临床医生与实践领导者进行半结构化访谈,探讨患者、临床医生、实践、卫生系统、环境和指南六个层面因素对新或变更的预防指南采纳的交互影响。结果显示指南采纳受多层面复杂交互影响,而非单一因素决定。
要点
- 指南采纳受患者、临床医生、实践、系统、环境和指南特征多层面因素交互影响。
- 媒体和专科医生对指南采纳的影响大于保险覆盖或交通等传统环境因素。
- 不同实践场所对指南实施侧重卫生系统、实践或临床医生不同层面。
核心结论
- 指南采纳受患者、临床医生、实践、卫生系统、环境和指南特征多层面因素的复杂交互影响。
- 全面理解每个具体临床环境的所有影响层面,可能有助于确定改善循证指南采纳的最佳干预措施。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,于2018年对多元化的临床医生和实践领导者进行半结构化访谈。
- 采用沉浸-结晶法识别涌现主题。
主要发现
- 受访者表达遵循指南的动机,但也重视与患者共享决策。
- 个人偏见和恐惧影响临床医生和患者对指南的采纳。
- 实践通过工作流程优化和鼓励循证实践文化促进实施,卫生系统的关键功能是维护电子健康记录警报。
- 媒体和专科医生的影响比保险覆盖或交通等传统环境因素对指南采纳和实施的阻碍更小。
- 各种具体的指南特征也影响采纳和实施的难易程度。
临床怎么用
- 在推动新或变更的预防指南落地时,应综合评估患者、临床医生、实践、卫生系统、环境和指南特征多个层面的影响因素。
- 针对具体临床环境识别各层面影响,有助于选择最优干预措施以提高循证指南采纳。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Despite widespread recognition that adherence to clinical preventive guidelines improves patient outcomes, clinicians struggle to implement guideline changes in a timely manner. Multiple factors influence guideline adoption and effective implementation. However, few studies evaluate their collective and inter-related effects. This qualitative study provides a comprehensive picture of the interplay between multiple factors on uptake of new or changed preventive guidelines. METHODS: Semistructured interviews conducted in 2018 with a diverse sample of clinicians and practice leaders sought to understand patient, clinician, practice, health system, environment, and guideline factors of influence. An immersion-crystallization approach was used to identify emergent themes. RESULTS: Interviewees expressed motivation to adhere to guidelines but also valued sharing decisions with patients. Personal biases and fears affected both clinician and patient guideline adoption. Practices facilitated implementation through workflow optimization and encouraging a culture of evidence-based practice while a key health system function was to maintain electronic health record alerts. More traditional environmental factors, such as insurance coverage or transportation, were less of a barrier to guideline adoption and implementation than the influence of media and specialists. Various specific guideline characteristics also affected ease of adoption and implementation. Different settings expressed greater health system, practice, or clinician-centric approaches to guideline implementation. CONCLUSIONS: Guideline uptake is influenced by a complex interplay of multiple levels of factors including the patient, clinician, practice, health system, environment, and guideline levels. Comprehensively understanding all levels of influence for each specific clinical setting may help to determine the optimal intervention(s) for improving uptake of evidence-based guidelines.
引用
- Jiang V, Brooks EM, Tong ST, et al. Factors Influencing Uptake of Changes to Clinical Preventive Guidelines. J Am Board Fam Med. 2020. PMID: 32179610. doi:10.3122/jabfm.2020.02.190146
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。