数字干预对急性病患儿父母及就医行为影响的系统综述
该系统综述检索MEDLINE和EMBASE至2019年1月,纳入3项评估数字干预(2个应用程序和1个网站)对急性病患儿父母自我分诊和就医行为影响的研究。结果显示自我分诊干预敏感性较高(84%和93.3%)但特异性较低(74%和13%),且没有任何干预能减少紧急护理服务的使用。证据不足以支持使用数字干预帮助父母决定自我护理或就医。
要点
- 仅3项研究评估数字干预对患儿父母就医决策的影响,且均未让父母参与干预开发。
- 自我分诊工具敏感性84%-93.3%,但特异性仅74%和13%,可能增加不必要的就医。
- 没有证据表明数字干预能减少紧急护理服务的使用。
核心结论
- 证据不足以支持使用数字干预帮助父母或照护者决定急性病患儿是否自我护理或就医。
研究设计与样本
- 系统综述,检索MEDLINE和EMBASE从建库至2019年1月,纳入任何设计的研究,评估数字干预对急性病患儿父母的影响。
主要发现
- 纳入3项研究,评估2个应用程序和1个网站:Children's On-Call(美国,仅提供建议)、Should I See a Doctor?(荷兰,针对任何急性病的自我分诊应用)、SORT for Kids(美国,针对流感样疾病的自我分诊网站)。
- 没有研究让父母参与干预开发,且许多父母认为两个应用程序不易使用。
- Should I See a Doctor?与护士分诊相比敏感性84%,SORT for Kids与需要急诊干预相比敏感性93.3%,但两者特异性较低(分别为74%和13%)。
- 没有任何干预显示减少紧急护理服务的使用。
关键数值与推荐
- Should I See a Doctor?与护士分诊相比敏感性84%、特异性74%。
- SORT for Kids与需要急诊干预相比敏感性93.3%、特异性13%。
临床怎么用
- 目前不推荐常规使用数字干预帮助父母决定急性病患儿是否就医。
- 未来数字干预开发应让父母参与,并需要足够效能的试验评估其对健康服务使用和识别重症患儿的影响。
局限性
- 仅纳入3项研究,证据量少。
- 研究涉及的干预类型和疾病范围有限。
- 没有研究让父母参与干预开发,且部分干预易用性差。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Consultations for self-limiting infections in children are increasing. It has been proposed that digital technology could be used to enable parents' decision making in terms of self-care and treatment seeking. AIM: To evaluate the evidence that digital interventions facilitate parents deciding whether to self-care or seek treatment for acute illnesses in children. DESIGN AND SETTING: Systematic review of studies undertaken worldwide. METHOD: Searches of MEDLINE and EMBASE were made to identify studies (of any design) published between database inception and January 2019 that assessed digital interventions for parents of children (from any healthcare setting) with acute illnesses. The primary outcome of interest was whether the use of digital interventions reduced the use of urgent care services. RESULTS: Three studies were included in the review. They assessed two apps and one website: Children's On-Call - a US advice-only app; Should I See a Doctor? - a Dutch self-triage app for any acute illness; and Strategy for Off-Site Rapid Triage (SORT) for Kids - a US self-triage website for influenza-like illness. None of the studies involved parents during intervention development and it was shown that many parents did not find the two apps easy to use. The sensitivity of self-triage interventions was 84% for Should I See a Doctor? compared with nurse triage, and 93.3% for SORT for Kids compared with the need for emergency-department intervention; however, both had lower specificity (74% and 13%, respectively). None of the interventions demonstrated reduced use of urgent-care services. CONCLUSION: There is little evidence to support the use of digital interventions to help parent and/or carers looking after children with acute illness. Future research should involve parents during intervention development, and adequately powered trials are needed to assess the impact of such interventions on health services and the identification of children who are seriously ill.
引用
- Donovan E, Wilcox CR, Patel S, et al. Digital interventions for parents of acutely ill children and their treatment-seeking behaviour: a systematic review. Br J Gen Pract. 2020. PMID: 32041764. doi:10.3399/bjgp20X708209
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。