医院到家庭安全过渡的威胁:伦敦西北部初级保健共识研究
本研究采用三轮德尔菲共识法,纳入英格兰伦敦西北部39家初级保健机构的临床与非临床人员,识别医院向初级保健过渡中的关键威胁。第一轮识别出九个威胁,涵盖沟通、服务组织、药物提供和高风险患者。交接指令质量差获最高重要性评分(第三轮均值8.43)且100%共识为非常重要;老年人和服用超过5种药物的复杂患者最脆弱;抗凝药被认为风险最高。
要点
- 交接指令质量差是医院向初级保健过渡中最被重视的威胁(均值8.43,100%共识)。
- 老年人和服用超过5种药物的复杂患者被认为最脆弱。
- 抗凝药被认为对患者构成最大风险。
核心结论
- 研究识别了医院向初级保健安全过渡的具体威胁,为政策制定者和医疗提供者提供了质量改进策略的目标。
研究设计与样本
- 三轮网络德尔菲共识过程,纳入英格兰伦敦西北部39家初级保健机构的临床与非临床人员。
- 第一轮为自由文本想法产生轮,第二和第三轮为获取共识的评分轮。
- 鼓励各机构在团队会议中完成问卷。
主要发现
- 第一轮识别出九个威胁,涉及沟通、服务组织、药物提供和高风险患者。
- 交接指令质量差获最高评分(第三轮均值8.43)且100%共识为非常重要。
- 老年人(97%)和服用超过5种药物的复杂医疗问题患者(80%)被投票为最脆弱。
- 抗凝药(77%)被认为对患者构成最大风险。
关键数值与推荐
- 共识定义为≥75%。
- 重要性评分1-3为不重要,4-6为有些重要,7-9为非常重要。
临床怎么用
- 临床团队可将交接指令质量、老年人、多重用药患者和抗凝药作为质量改进的优先靶点。
局限性
- 研究未报告威胁背后的因素,需进一步工作识别以便定制干预措施。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Transitions between healthcare settings are vulnerable points for patients. AIM: To identify key threats to safe patient transitions from hospital to primary care settings. DESIGN AND SETTING: Three-round web-based Delphi consensus process among clinical and non-clinical staff from 39 primary care practices in North West London, England. METHOD: Round 1 was a free-text idea-generating round. Rounds 2 and 3 were consensus-obtaining rating rounds. Practices were encouraged to complete the questionnaires at team meetings. Aggregate ratings of perceived level of importance for each threat were calculated (1-3: 'not important', 4-6: 'somewhat important', 7-9: 'very important'). Percentage of votes cast for each patient or medication group were recorded; consensus was defined as ≥75%. RESULTS: A total of 39 practices completed round 1, 36/39 (92%) completed round 2, and 30/36 (83%) completed round 3. Round 1 identified nine threats encompassing problems involving communication, service organisation, medication provision, and patients who were most at risk. 'Poor quality of handover instructions from secondary to primary care teams' achieved the highest rating (mean rating at round 3 = 8.43) and a 100% consensus that it was a 'very important' threat. Older individuals (97%) and patients with complex medical problems taking >5 medications (80%) were voted the most vulnerable. Anticoagulants (77%) were considered to pose the greatest risk to patients. CONCLUSION: This study identified specific threats to safe patient transitions from hospital to primary care, providing policymakers and healthcare providers with targets for quality improvement strategies. Further work would need to identify factors underpinning these threats so that interventions can be tailored to the relevant behavioural and environmental contexts in which these threats arise.
引用
- Markiewicz O, Lavelle M, Lorencatto F, et al. Threats to safe transitions from hospital to home: a consensus study in North West London primary care. Br J Gen Pract. 2019. PMID: 31848201. doi:10.3399/bjgp19X707105
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。