美国初级保健医生特征及其实践与预先护理计划对话的关联
研究分析2015年联邦基金国际调查中1001名美国初级保健医生数据,探讨医生及实践特征与对年老体弱患者开展预先护理计划(ACP)对话的关系。多变量分析显示郊区执业与较少ACP对话相关,而常见多病共存或姑息需求患者、提供家访及部分按人头付费与更多ACP对话相关;APCP/PCMH特征指数得分越高,ACP对话越多。
要点
- 郊区执业的医生报告常规ACP对话较少。
- 实践常见多病共存或姑息需求患者、提供家访与更多ACP对话相关。
- 部分按人头付费的医生更可能报告ACP对话。
核心结论
- 患者类型、执业地点和医生补偿方式影响美国初级保健医生是否常规与年老体弱患者讨论ACP。
- 展现更多APCP/PCMH模型特征的实践也与ACP对话相关。
研究设计与样本
- 分析2015年联邦基金国际调查中1001名美国初级保健医生的数据。
- 多变量分析医生及实践特征与ACP对话的关联,并构建APCP/PCMH特征指数作为实践协变量。
主要发现
- 受访者以男性(60%)和≥45岁(74%)为主。
- 郊区执业与较少ACP对话相关。
- 实践常见多病共存或姑息需求患者、提供家访与更多ACP对话相关。
- 部分按人头付费的医生更可能报告ACP对话。
- 单一APCP/PCMH条目与ACP对话无关联,但APCP/PCMH特征指数得分越高与更多ACP对话相关。
临床怎么用
- 在郊区执业的初级保健实践中,可针对年老体弱患者加强ACP对话的常规开展。
- 关注多病共存或姑息需求患者、提供家访及采用部分按人头付费可能促进ACP对话。
- 推进APCP/PCMH特征建设可能有助于增加ACP对话。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
INTRODUCTION: Primary care practices are essential settings for Advance Care Planning (ACP) conversations with patients. We hypothesized that such conversations occur more routinely in Advanced Primary Care/Patient Centered Medical Home (APCP/PCMH) Practices using practice transformation strategies. METHODS: We analyzed characteristics of physician respondents and their practices associated with ACP discussions in older and sicker patients using US data from the 2015 Commonwealth Fund International Survey of Primary Care Physicians in 10 Nations. The primary outcome was how routinely these ACP conversations are reported. We developed an index of APCP/PCMH features as a practice covariable. RESULTS: Respondents (N = 1001) were predominantly male (60%) and ≥45 years old (74%). Multivariable analyses showed that suburban practice location was associated with fewer ACP conversations; working in a practice commonly seeing patients with multiple chronic conditions or who have palliative care needs, and working in a practice from which home visits are made, were associated with more ACP conversations. Physicians compensated in part by capitation were more likely to report ACP conversations. No association was found between a single item asking if the practice was an APCP/PCMH and having ACP conversations. However, higher scores on an index of APCP/PCMH features were associated with more ACP conversations. CONCLUSIONS: In this sample of US primary care physicians, the types of patients seen, practice location, and physician compensation influenced whether physicians routinely discuss ACP with patients who are older and sicker. Practices demonstrating more features of APCP/PCMH models of primary care are also associated with ACP discussions.
引用
- Nowels D, Nowels MA, Sheffler JL, et al. Features of U.S. Primary Care Physicians and Their Practices Associated with Advance Care Planning Conversations. J Am Board Fam Med. 2019. PMID: 31704752. doi:10.3122/jabfm.2019.06.190017
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。