科罗拉多大学初级保健重塑模型下的实践转型
本研究比较了两家家庭医学诊所实施初级保健重塑(PCR)团队模型的转型经历,该模型将医疗助理与临床医师比例从约1:2提高至2.5:1并扩展医疗助理角色。结果显示,试点诊所在总预约量、高血压控制、结直肠癌筛查及多数糖尿病质量指标上改善;第二波诊所在实施后总预约量大幅增加,高血压控制快速改善,结直肠癌筛查加速改善,糖尿病指标先稳定或下降后改善。临床医师所有体验领域随时间改善,倦怠减少至少一半,员工工时每就诊保持稳定。
要点
- PCR模型提高医疗助理与临床医师比例至2.5:1并扩展其角色。
- 试点诊所总预约量及多项质量指标改善,第二波诊所实施后预约量大幅增加。
- 临床医师倦怠减少至少一半,员工工时每就诊保持稳定。
核心结论
- PCR模型与质量、可及性和临床医师体验的同时改善相关,并减少倦怠,同时保持人员成本。
研究设计与样本
- 比较两家家庭医学诊所实施PCR团队模型前后的转型经历,试点诊所2015年2月实施,第二波诊所2017年2月实施。
- 评估实施前至少7个月及实施后42个月的可及性、临床质量指标、人员成本和临床医师及员工体验与倦怠。
主要发现
- 试点诊所总预约量、高血压控制率、结直肠癌筛查率及多数糖尿病质量指标较实施前改善。
- 第二波诊所实施前增加临床医师时总预约量略增,实施后大幅增加;高血压控制初始多变,实施后快速改善。
- 第二波诊所结直肠癌筛查逐渐改善后加速,糖尿病指标初始稳定或下降后改善。
- 两家诊所新患者预约在2015年末开始增加,试点诊所在PCR下增长更快。
- 临床医师所有体验领域随时间改善,员工多数稳定;倦怠减少至少一半,低人员配置期除外。
关键数值与推荐
- PCR模型将医疗助理与临床医师比例从约1:2提高至2.5:1。
- 医疗助理角色扩展包括增强备诊流程、诊室内支持(如记录)、临床医师后收尾及收件箱协助。
临床怎么用
- 可参考PCR模型通过提高医疗助理比例和扩展其角色来改善可及性、质量指标及临床医师体验。
- 实施后需关注低人员配置期对倦怠和员工的负面影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: We compared the transformation experience of 2 family medicine practices that implemented the Primary Care Redesign (PCR) team-based model to improve access, quality, and experience without increasing cost. The University of Colorado's A.F. Williams Family Medicine clinic (pilot practice) implemented the model in February 2015, and a smaller, community-based practice (wave 2 practice) did so 2 years later, in February 2017. METHODS: The PCR model increased the ratio of medical assistants to clinicians from about 1:2 to 2.5:1 while expanding the role of the medical assistants, through enhanced rooming procedures, in-room support (eg, scribing), postclinician wrap-up, and in-basket assistance. We assessed access, clinical quality metrics, staffing costs, and clinician and staff experience and burnout for at least 7 months before and 42 months after the intervention. RESULTS: In the pilot practice, compared with preimplementation, there were improvements in total appointments and rates of hypertension control, colorectal cancer screening, and most diabetic quality metrics. In the wave 2 practice, total appointments increased slightly when clinicians were added pre-PCR and then increased substantially after implementation; initially variable hypertension control improved rapidly after implementation. The wave 2 practice's colorectal cancer screening improved gradually, then accelerated postimplementation, while diabetic metrics initially remained stable or declined, then improved postimplementation. New patient appointments began to increase for both practices in late 2015, but grew faster in the pilot practice under PCR. Over time, all experiential domains improved for clinicians; most remained stable for staff. Clinician burnout was reduced by at least one-half in both practices except during low staffing periods, which also adversely affected staff. After a ramp-up period, the number of staff hours per visit remained stable. CONCLUSIONS: The PCR model is associated with simultaneous improvements in quality, access, and clinician experience, as well as reductions in burnout, while maintaining staffing costs.
引用
- Smith PC, Lyon C, English AF, et al. Practice Transformation Under the University of Colorado's Primary Care Redesign Model. Ann Fam Med. 2019. PMID: 31405873. doi:10.1370/afm.2424
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。