邮寄信件与电话提醒对提高癌症筛查参与率的随机试验
在加拿大多伦多学术初级保健机构的6家诊所开展实用性随机试验,比较邮寄信件与个性化电话提醒对宫颈癌、乳腺癌和结直肠癌筛查逾期患者的筛查参与率。女性中电话提醒组至少完成一项筛查的比例为41.2%,信件组为33.0%(绝对差8.1%,95%CI 5.1%-11.2%,P<.001);男性中电话组结直肠癌筛查率为28.8%,信件组为24.8%(绝对差4.1%,95%CI -0.4%至8.5%,P=.073)。电话提醒更有效但成本更高。
要点
- 女性中电话提醒提高至少一项癌症筛查参与率优于信件(41.2% vs 33.0%)。
- 男性中电话与信件对结直肠癌筛查率的差异无统计学意义(P=.073)。
- 电话提醒每完成一例筛查的成本高于信件。
核心结论
- 电话提醒在提高女性宫颈癌、乳腺癌和结直肠癌筛查参与率方面比邮寄信件更有效,但成本更高。
研究设计与样本
- 实用性随机试验,在加拿大多伦多学术初级保健机构的6家诊所开展,比较邮寄信件与个性化电话提醒对筛查逾期患者的效果。
- 共随机分配3733名女性和1537名男性,主要结局为至少完成一项逾期筛查,采用意向性治疗、未调整比例比较的χ2检验,并按性别分层分析。
主要发现
- 女性中电话提醒组41.2%完成至少一项筛查,信件组33.0%,绝对差8.1%(95%CI 5.1%-11.2%,P<.001)。
- 男性中电话提醒组28.8%完成结直肠癌筛查,信件组24.8%,绝对差4.1%(95%CI -0.4%至8.5%,P=.073)。
- 女性每完成一例筛查信件成本约CaD $5.07,电话约CaD $8.71;男性信件约CaD $7.16,电话约CaD $12.00。
临床怎么用
- 初级保健机构可考虑将电话提醒整合到癌症筛查外展中,可能作为靶向或分阶段外展策略的一部分。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: There is good evidence that cancer-specific patient outreach improves rates of cervical, breast, and colorectal cancer screening. However, it is unclear how primary care practices should implement integrated outreach for all 3 types of cancer screening. We aimed to understand whether integrated outreach using mailed letters or phone calls were more effective at increasing screening uptake in a primary care organization. METHOD: We conducted a pragmatic randomized trial comparing outreach by mailed letter or personalized phone call for patients overdue for cervical, breast, or colorectal cancer screening. The study was conducted at 6 clinics within an academic primary care organization in Toronto, Canada. Our primary outcome was an uptake of at least 1 screening test for which the patient was overdue. Our primary analysis was an intention-to-treat, unadjusted comparison of proportions, using a χ2 test. We also compared costs per additional patient screened. All analyses were stratified by sex. RESULTS: A total of 3733 females and 1537 males were randomized to receive 1 of the interventions. Among women, 33.0% allocated to receive a reminder letter and 41.2% allocated to receive a reminder phone call received at least 1 screening test for which they were due (absolute difference, 8.1%; 95% CI, 5.1%-11.2%, P < .001). Among men, 24.8% allocated to receive a reminder letter and 28.8% allocated to a reminder phone call received screening for colorectal cancer (absolute difference, 4.1%; 95% CI, -0.4% to 8.5%, P = .073). For women and men, the letters cost approximately CaD $5.07 and CaD $7.16, respectively, for each completed screening test compared with CaD $8.71 and CaD $12.00 for the phone calls. CONCLUSIONS: Phone calls were more effective than mailed letters at increasing uptake for cervical, breast, and colorectal cancer screening among women. However, phone calls were more expensive than letters. Primary care practices should consider integrating phone call reminders into their practice, possibly as part of a targeted or staged approach to outreach for cancer screening.
引用
- Kiran T, Davie S, Moineddin R, et al. Mailed Letter Versus Phone Call to Increase Uptake of Cancer Screening: A Pragmatic, Randomized Trial. J Am Board Fam Med. 2018. PMID: 30413542. doi:10.3122/jabfm.2018.06.170369
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。