招募基层医疗诊所参与研究的反思与提醒
本文基于一项在两州36家诊所开展的2型糖尿病自我管理支持整群随机试验,反思诊所招募过程。结果显示所有36家诊所均完成研究,但早期充分招募需大量努力,总结出需在多层级招募更多利益相关者、招募是过程且可能因人员更替延长的教训。
要点
- 招募需覆盖诊所、系统及不同角色的更多利益相关者
- 招募是过程,可能因关键联系人更替而长于预期
- 需制定结构化沟通策略以维持全程参与
核心结论
- 在需要大量诊所改变的实用临床试验中,PBRN领导者应制定全面策略识别并吸引诊所内广泛利益相关者,理解其需求并设计结构化沟通策略以维持全程参与。
研究设计与样本
- 对一项两州、36家诊所的整群随机试验的现场笔记、半结构化临床医生和员工访谈及会议笔记进行迭代定性分析。
主要发现
- 所有36家入组诊所均完成研究,但早期充分招募诊所耗费大量努力。
- 总结出两点主要教训:PBRN须在诊所、系统及不同角色等多层级招募更多利益相关者;招募是过程,可能因关键联系人非计划更替而长于预期。
临床怎么用
- 调整招募策略需帮助诊所沟通、使研究信息契合利益相关者兴趣、允许诊所层面微调以匹配工作流程人员资源、随时间重新接触临床领导、因人员更替确定备份倡导者。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Recruiting primary care practices for research projects has always required carefully tended relationships, a compelling message, and good timing. Recruiting practices to participate in practice transformation research trials may take more and different efforts. We reflect on practice recruitment for a recently-concluded trial of a diabetes self-management support system in 2 states and 36 practices. METHODS: Iterative qualitative analysis of field notes, semistructured clinician and staff interviews, and meeting notes from a 2-state, cluster-randomized trial that aimed to improve self-management support for patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus. RESULTS: Although all 36 enrolled practices finished the study, fully recruiting practices early on took considerable effort, yielding 2 primary lessons: 1) practice-based research networks (PBRNs) must recruit more stakeholders at more levels, at the clinic, in the system, and across roles; and 2) practice recruitment is a process and may take longer than expected with unplanned turnover of key contacts. Adjusting our recruitment strategies required: helping with communication efforts in practices; aligning our study message according to stakeholders' interests; allowing for minor adaptations at the practice-level to align with critical practice workflows, staffing, and resources; re-engaging with clinical leadership over time; and identifying a "backup" champion due to turnover. CONCLUSIONS: When undertaking a pragmatic clinical trial requiring substantial practice change in a PBRN setting across a large number of practices, it is important that PBRN leaders develop a comprehensive strategy to identify and engage a broad group of stakeholders within each practice, understand their needs and priorities around research, and design and implement a structured communications strategy to maintain engagement throughout every phase of the project.
引用
- Fernald DH, Jortberg BT, Hessler DM, et al. Recruiting Primary Care Practices for Research: Reflections and Reminders. J Am Board Fam Med. 2018. PMID: 30413552. doi:10.3122/jabfm.2018.06.180025
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。