基层儿科保健就诊中的筛查:一项质量改进研究
该研究在学术家庭医学诊所采用混合方法质量改进干预,评估183名儿童干预前和151名儿童干预后发育、贫血、铅、口腔健康、视力及听力筛查率。干预后贫血检测、血铅检测、口腔健康筛查与转诊、视力及听力检测的医嘱和确认率均显著改善(P < .05),但静脉采血困难、视力筛查抵触和听力设备适配问题仍为障碍。
要点
- 质量改进干预可显著提高儿童保健中贫血、铅、口腔健康、视力和听力筛查率。
- 静脉采血困难、医疗助理对视力筛查的抵触及听力设备不适配是进一步改善的障碍。
- 后续持续质量改进采用指尖血红蛋白检测、儿童友好型视力筛查仪和带头戴式耳机的手动听力计。
核心结论
- 基于质量改进理论的诊所干预可潜在改善儿童保健筛查率,但需进一步解决操作与设备障碍。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法干预研究,采用质量改进理论,在学术家庭医学诊所进行干预前(183名儿童)与干预后(151名儿童)筛查率评估,并采用小组访谈和关键知情人访谈进行定性分析。
主要发现
- 干预后贫血检测医嘱率、血清铅检测医嘱率、口腔健康筛查与转诊率、视力及听力检测的医嘱和确认率均显著改善(P < .05)。
- 定性分析发现进一步改善的障碍包括静脉采血困难、医疗助理对视力筛查的抵触以及听力评估设备适配性差。
关键数值与推荐
- 干预措施包括用户友好材料、检查清单、海报、教育和医嘱套餐。
- 后续持续质量改进活动采用指尖血红蛋白检测、儿童友好型视力筛查仪和带头戴式耳机的手动听力计。
临床怎么用
- 在基层儿童保健中可借鉴用户友好材料、检查清单、海报、教育和医嘱套餐等多组分质量改进策略提升筛查率。
- 针对静脉采血、视力筛查抵触和听力设备适配等障碍,可考虑指尖血红蛋白检测、儿童友好型视力筛查仪和带头戴式耳机的手动听力计。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Early Periodic Screening, Diagnosis, and Treatment visits are designed to address physical, mental, and developmental health of children enrolled in Medicaid. METHODS: We conducted a mixed methods intervention by using a quality improvement theory. We assessed preintervention and postintervention screening rates of development, anemia, lead, oral health, vision and hearing, interventions for improvement, and barriers for the well-child visits at an academic family medicine clinic. For quantitative analysis, we assessed the preintervention baseline for 183 children and postintervention outcome for 151 children. For qualitative analysis, we used group interviews and key informant interviews to develop interventions in the preintervention stage and to explore potential barriers for further improvement in the postintervention stage. RESULTS: Interventions based on baseline results included user-friendly materials, checklists, posters, education, and order sets. After the intervention, there were significant statistical improvements (P < .05) for the anemia test ordered rate, serum lead test ordered rate, oral health screening and referral rates, and ordered and confirmed test rates for both vision and hearing. Despite these improvements, 3 qualitative findings indicated barriers for further improvement, including difficulties in venipuncture, medical assistant aversion to vision screening, and poor fit of equipment for hearing assessment. The procedures prompted further continuous quality improvement activities using fingerstick hemoglobin testing, a child-friendly vision screener, and manual audiometer with headphones. CONCLUSIONS: The trial findings demonstrated potential benefits of improving screenings in an office-based intervention by using a quality improvement process. Postintervention qualitative findings illustrate additional factors that could be addressed for further improvements.
引用
- Wakai T, Simasek M, Nakagawa U, et al. Screenings during Well-Child Visits in Primary Care: A Quality Improvement Study. J Am Board Fam Med. 2018. PMID: 29986982. doi:10.3122/jabfm.2018.04.170222
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。