多病共存复诊中提升患者中心性的计算机模板:定性评价
结果显示模板初期干扰沟通,但首问患者重要健康问题能引出广泛关切,患者欢迎更全面复诊,部分临床医生担忧分散慢病管理注意力,目标设定多由医生主导。
要点
- 复诊模板首问患者重要健康问题可有效引出广泛健康关切
- 患者欢迎更全面整体的复诊,部分未满足需求被识别
- 部分临床医生认为患者议程分散了长期疾病管理注意力
核心结论
- 在长期疾病复诊模板中加入患者中心性问题可能改善患者对复诊患者中心性的感知,尽管模板对临床医生注意力有要求。
- 应考虑在标准化复诊中增加关于患者主要关切的初始问题。
研究设计与样本
- 对一项在英格兰和苏格兰33家全科诊所开展的随机对照试验进行定性过程评价,该试验评估以患者为中心的复杂干预对多病共存管理的影响。
主要发现
- 干预复诊中沟通中断更明显,因为模板不熟悉。
- 模板第一个关于患者重要健康问题的问题成功引出了广泛的健康关切。
- 患者欢迎更全面、综合的复诊,并识别出一些未满足的医疗需求。
- 大多数临床医生重视识别患者议程,但部分认为这分散了对长期疾病护理的注意力。
- 目标设定由全科医生主导,而非协作。
临床怎么用
- 在多病共存复诊中,可考虑在标准化复诊模板开头询问患者最重要的健康问题,以引出广泛关切。
- 使用新模板初期可能干扰沟通,需关注临床医生对模板的熟悉程度。
- 识别患者议程时需平衡长期疾病管理注意力。
- 目标设定应促进协作而非医生主导。
局限性
- 原文未明确报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Computer templates for review of single long-term conditions are commonly used to record care processes, but they may inhibit communication and prevent patients from discussing their wider concerns. AIM: To evaluate the effect on patient-centredness of a novel computer template used in multimorbidity reviews. DESIGN AND SETTING: A qualitative process evaluation of a randomised controlled trial in 33 GP practices in England and Scotland examining the implementation of a patient-centred complex intervention intended to improve management of multimorbidity. A purpose-designed computer template combining long-term condition reviews was used to support the patient-centred intervention. METHOD: Twenty-eight reviews using the intervention computer template and nine usual-care reviews were observed and recorded. Sixteen patient interviews, four patient focus groups, and 23 clinician interviews were also conducted in eight of the 12 intervention practices. Transcripts were thematically analysed based on predefined core components of patient-centredness and template use. RESULTS: Disrupted communication was more evident in intervention reviews because the template was unfamiliar, but the first template question about patients' important health issues successfully elicited wide-ranging health concerns. Patients welcomed the more holistic, comprehensive reviews, and some unmet healthcare needs were identified. Most clinicians valued identifying patients' agendas, but some felt it diverted attention from care of long-term conditions. Goal-setting was GP-led rather than collaborative. CONCLUSION: Including patient-centred questions in long-term condition review templates appears to improve patients' perceptions about the patient-centredness of reviews, despite template demands on a clinician's attention. Adding an initial question in standardised reviews about the patient's main concerns should be considered.
引用
- Mann C, Shaw A, Wye L, et al. A computer template to enhance patient-centredness in multimorbidity reviews: a qualitative evaluation in primary care. Br J Gen Pract. 2018. PMID: 29784866. doi:10.3399/bjgp18X696353
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。