说服性干预用于争议性癌症筛查建议:一种帮助患者做出循证决策的新方法测试
本研究基于前期定性工作与行为科学文献,制作了关于前列腺癌筛查和40-49岁女性乳腺癌筛查的医生-患者讨论视频片段及配套幻灯片,在27名50-74岁男性和35名40-49岁女性中开展随机交叉重复测量研究,比较视频干预与纸质决策辅助对筛查意向、获益与危害感知及决策冲突的影响。结果显示视频干预显著改变了筛查意向,而纸质干预无显著变化。
要点
- 视频干预使男性筛查意向均值变化-0.93(P<.001),女性-0.50(P<.001)。
- 纸质干预后男性变化0.0、女性-0.06(P=.75),无显著改变。
- 研究结束时33%男性及49%女性仍希望筛查,11%和20%不确定。
核心结论
- 新型说服性视频干预显著改变了相当比例观看者的筛查意向。
- 该方法需进一步测试,但可能为帮助患者考虑并接受循证但反直觉的建议提供模型。
研究设计与样本
- 随机交叉重复测量研究,纳入27名50-74岁男性和35名40-49岁女性。
- 所有参与者以随机顺序观看视频干预和更传统的纸质决策辅助干预。
- 在入组时及观看每种干预后调查筛查意向、获益与危害感知及决策冲突。
主要发现
- 基线时69%男性及86%女性希望筛查,31%和6%不确定。
- 视频干预后男性筛查意向均值变化-0.93(P<.001),女性-0.50(P<.001)。
- 纸质干预后男性变化0.0、女性-0.06(P=.75)。
- 研究结束时33%男性及49%女性希望筛查,11%和20%不确定。
关键数值与推荐
- 视频干预基于美国预防服务工作组(USPSTF)2012年前列腺癌筛查建议和2009年40-49岁女性乳腺X线筛查建议。
- 筛查意向采用3点量表(是、不确定、否)测量。
临床怎么用
- 视频干预可用于帮助患者理解并接受有争议的循证筛查建议。
- 纸质决策辅助在改变筛查意向方面效果不显著。
局限性
- 样本量较小(27名男性、35名女性),需进一步测试。
- 原文未报告其他局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: We wanted to evaluate novel decision aids designed to help patients trust and accept the controversial, evidence-based, US Preventive Services Task Force recommendations about prostate cancer screening (from 2012) and mammography screening for women aged 40 to 49 years (from 2009). METHODS: We created recorded vignettes of physician-patient discussions about prostate cancer screening and mammography, accompanied by illustrative slides, based on principles derived from preceding qualitative work and behavioral science literature. We conducted a randomized crossover study with repeated measures with 27 men aged 50 to 74 years and 35 women aged 40 to 49 years. All participants saw a video intervention and a more traditional, paper-based decision aid intervention in random order. At entry and after seeing each intervention, they were surveyed about screening intentions, perceptions of benefits and harm, and decisional conflict. RESULTS: Changes in screening intentions were analyzed without regard to order of intervention after an initial analyses showed no evidence of an order effect. At baseline, 69% of men and 86% of women reported wanting screening, with 31% and 6%, respectively, unsure. Mean change on a 3-point, yes, unsure, no scale was -0.93 (P = <.001) for men and -0.50 (P = <.001) for women after seeing the video interventions vs 0.0 and -0.06 (P = .75) after seeing the print interventions. At the study end, 33% of men and 49% of women wanted screening, and 11% and 20%, respectively, were unsure. CONCLUSIONS: Our novel, persuasive video interventions significantly changed the screening intentions of substantial proportions of viewers. Our approach needs further testing but may provide a model for helping patients to consider and accept evidence-based, counterintuitive recommendations.
引用
- Saver BG, Mazor KM, Luckmann R, et al. Persuasive Interventions for Controversial Cancer Screening Recommendations: Testing a Novel Approach to Help Patients Make Evidence-Based Decisions. Ann Fam Med. 2017. PMID: 28376460. doi:10.1370/afm.1996
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。