从临床试验到常规照护:基层医生对老年结直肠癌筛查共享决策干预体验的定性分析
该定性研究基于PRIMED整群随机试验,访谈了43名参与试验的基层医生,探讨其在老年(76-85岁)结直肠癌筛查中实施共享决策培训与提醒的体验。医生认为培训与提醒有助于更个体化的筛查讨论,但时间压力、竞争性优先事项和COVID-19疫情等现实限制挑战实施,建议通过系统层面整合(如自动化提醒、患者决策辅助、简短培训和跨专业协作)来推广。
要点
- 培训与提醒支持基层医生对76-85岁成人进行更个体化的结直肠癌筛查共享决策讨论。
- 时间压力、竞争性优先事项和COVID-19疫情等现实限制挑战共享决策的常规实施。
- 推广共享决策需系统层面支持:自动化提醒、患者决策辅助、简短培训和跨专业协作。
核心结论
- 基层医生认为共享决策培训与提醒支持对老年成人结直肠癌筛查进行更细致和个体化的讨论。
- 为在基层广泛推广,干预应简化并整合到现有工作流程中以最小化医生负担。
- 对76-85岁成人,结直肠癌筛查决策应个体化并与基层医生共同制定。
研究设计与样本
- 定性研究,采用半结构化访谈,于2021年4月至7月进行。
- 邀请59名来自马萨诸塞州和缅因州5家医院附属35家基层诊所的PRIMED试验参与医生,最终43名参与访谈。
- 访谈逐字转录,由两名独立研究者采用框架分析知情方法分析。
主要发现
- 主题包括:培训与提醒支持共享决策;现实限制挑战实施但医生努力适应;推广和维持共享决策需要系统层面方法。
- 现实挑战包括时间压力、竞争性优先事项和COVID-19疫情。
- 医生建议改进实施:将提醒整合入电子健康记录、更短更灵活的培训、使用患者决策辅助和加强团队支持。
关键数值与推荐
- PRIMED整群随机试验发现,2小时在线培训联合就诊前提醒增加了76-85岁应进行结直肠癌筛查讨论患者的共享决策。
临床怎么用
- 对76-85岁成人,结直肠癌筛查决策应个体化并与基层医生共同制定。
- 采用自动化提醒、患者决策辅助、简短培训和跨专业协作以支持共享决策实施。
- 将共享决策工具整合到现有工作流程中以减少医生负担。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入马萨诸塞州和缅因州参与PRIMED试验的基层医生,可能限制推广性。
- 访谈在COVID-19疫情期间进行,疫情相关干扰可能影响医生体验。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: The Promoting Informed Decisions About Colorectal Cancer Screening in Older Adults (PRIMED) cluster randomized trial found that 2-hour online training combined with a pre-visit reminder for primary care physicians (PCPs) increased shared decision making (SDM) among patients aged 76-85 years who were due for colorectal cancer screening (CRC) screening discussions. However, the best way to translate findings from the clinical trial setting into routine primary care remains unclear. OBJECTIVE: To explore PCPs' experiences with the PRIMED SDM training and reminders, and to identify barriers, facilitators, and recommendations for implementation in routine primary care. METHODS: A qualitative study using semi-structured interviews was conducted. 59 PCPs from 35 primary care practices affiliated with five hospitals in Massachusetts and Maine who participated in the PRIMED trial were invited to be interviewed. Interviews were conducted between April and July 2021, transcribed verbatim, and analyzed by two independent researchers using a Framework Analysis-informed approach. RESULTS: Of 59 PCPs, 43 participated. Themes included: (i) Training and Reminders Supported SDM; (ii) Real-World Constraints Challenged SDM Implementation, but PCPs Made Efforts to Adapt despite challenges such as time pressures, competing priorities, and the COVID-19 pandemic; and (iii) Scaling and Sustaining SDM Requires a System-Level Approach, such as automated reminders, patient decision aids, concise training, and interprofessional SDM. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, PCPs perceived the SDM training and reminders as supporting a more nuanced and individualized approach to CRC screening conversations with older adults. To enable broader scale-up in primary care, these interventions should minimize burden on PCPs by streamlining integration into existing workflows. For adults aged 76–85, decisions about colorectal cancer screening should be individualized and made together with a primary care provider. A previous clinical trial (PRIMED) showed that a short online training and a reminder before the visit helped physicians have better shared decision-making conversations with their patients. In this study, we interviewed primary care physicians who participated in the trial to understand how this approach worked in real-world practice. Forty-three physicians from practices in Massachusetts and Maine shared their experiences. Physicians felt the training and reminders helped them have more thoughtful and personalized conversations about screening with older adults. However, they also described important challenges. Limited visit time, overlooking the reminder, competing health concerns, heavy workloads, and disruptions related to the COVID-19 pandemic made it difficult to consistently apply shared decision-making in routine care. Physicians suggested ways to improve implementation, including better integration of reminders into electronic health records, shorter and more flexible training options, use of patient decision aids, and greater team-based support. Overall, this study highlights that while shared decision-making tools can be helpful, successful implementation in everyday primary care must fit within physicians’ busy clinical workflows.
引用
- Kraun L, Chen E, Leavitt L, et al. Moving from a clinical trial to routine care: a qualitative analysis of primary care physicians' experiences with interventions to promote shared decision making for colorectal cancer screening in older adults. Fam Pract. 2026. PMID: 42837109. doi:10.1093/fampra/cmag075
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。