临床共情与关系连续性缓解多病共存患者的照护碎片化:一项质性研究
该研究通过对苏格兰四个整合健康与社会照护合作机构中28名多病共存患者及照护者的六组焦点小组进行质性分析,探讨复杂适应性照护系统中照护体验与行为的涌现与演变。研究发现,为应对需求增长而引入的服务变革常与患者复杂需求错位,促使患者和照护者调整行为以应对获取障碍;临床共情与关系连续性成为碎片化照护系统中的关键稳定因素。
要点
- 服务变革可能无意中 destabilise 照护,将负担转移给多病共存患者及照护者。
- 临床共情与关系连续性可稳定碎片化照护系统,影响信任与参与。
- 非正式照护扩张以填补系统缺口,家庭成员承担协调与倡导角色。
核心结论
- 旨在提高效率的服务变革可能无意中破坏照护稳定性,将负担转移给多病共存患者及照护者,影响感知照护质量与关系连续性。
- 主体间互动与关系质量塑造患者对照护的感知及未来参与。
研究设计与样本
- 质性研究,采用复杂适应性系统视角的溯因分析。
- 2024年2月至5月在苏格兰四个整合健康与社会照护合作机构开展六组焦点小组,共28名多病共存患者及照护者参与。
主要发现
- 多病共存患者的照护通过患者、照护者、专业人员与组织结构的动态互惠互动涌现。
- 为管理需求增长而引入的服务变革常被感知为与患者复杂需求错位,促使患者和照护者调整行为以应对获取障碍。
- 照护体验不可预测,受强化反馈循环塑造,其中小的个人互动对信任和参与产生不成比例的影响。
- 非正式照护扩张以填补系统缺口,家庭成员承担协调和倡导角色。
- 临床共情与关系连续性照护在碎片化照护系统中起关键稳定作用。
临床怎么用
- 在照护多病共存患者时,应重视临床共情与关系连续性的维护,以缓冲系统碎片化带来的负面影响。
- 关注服务变革对患者及照护者行为的意外影响,避免将协调负担不合理地转移给患者家庭。
- 识别并支持家庭成员在照护协调与倡导中的非正式角色。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入苏格兰四个整合健康与社会照护合作机构的28名患者及照护者,样本量和地域有限。
- 质性研究设计限制结论的普遍性推广。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Services for patients with multiple long-term conditions (MLTC) operate within fragmented and poorly coordinated systems but how care experiences, perceptions, and behaviours emerge and adapt in response to service changes and increasing system complexity is poorly understood. AIM: To explore how experiences and perceptions of care for patients with MLTC and their carers emerge and evolve within a complex adaptive care system to identify opportunities for better care. DESIGN AND SETTING: Qualitative analysis of six focus groups with 28 patients with MLTC and carers in four Scottish integrated health and social care partnerships was undertaken. METHOD: Data were collected between February and May 2024. Abductive analysis informed by a complex adaptive systems lens was used. RESULTS: Care for patients with MLTC emerged through dynamic, reciprocal interactions between patients, carers, professionals, and organisational structures. Service changes introduced to manage rising demand were often perceived as misaligned with patients' complex needs, prompting patients and carers to modify their behaviours to navigate access barriers. Care experiences were unpredictable, shaped by reinforcing feedback loops in which small personal interactions had a disproportionate effect on trust and engagement. Informal care expanded to fill system gaps, with family members assuming coordination and advocacy roles. Clinical empathy and relational continuity of care acted as key stabilising influences within fragmented care systems. CONCLUSION: Service changes intended to improve care efficiency can inadvertently destabilise care and shift the burden onto patients with MLTC and their carers, affecting perceived care quality and relational continuity. The quality of interactions and relationships between agents shape patients' perceptions of care and future engagement.
引用
- Arakelyan S, Guthrie B, Anand A, et al. Clinical empathy and relational continuity mitigate care fragmentation for patients with multiple long-term conditions: a qualitative study. Br J Gen Pract. 2026. PMID: 42767938. doi:10.3399/BJGP.2026.0171
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。