患者视角:癌症诊断前非癌诊断的影响——一项二次定性分析
该研究对英国基层医疗中7个访谈数据集进行二次定性分析,纳入58份记录,探讨患者在因疑似癌症转诊前接受非癌诊断(「中间诊断」)的经历。研究识别出八种常见情境,发现当患者感到症状未被充分理解或治疗不当时会质疑中间诊断,但信任对担忧有回应的临床医生。结论认为中间诊断是非特异症状诊断过程的正常部分,面对新证据时挑战这些诊断可减少诊断延迟。
要点
- 非特异症状患者接受中间非癌诊断是诊断过程的正常部分。
- 低风险患者症状常被归因于生活方式,需多次就诊才考虑进一步检查。
- 患者信任对担忧有回应的临床医生,无论最终诊断结果如何。
核心结论
- 中间非癌诊断是非特异症状患者诊断过程的正常组成部分,面对新证据时挑战这些诊断可减少诊断延迟并改善患者结局。
研究设计与样本
- 对英国基层医疗自2015年以来收集的7个访谈数据集进行二次定性分析,采用框架分析对患者旅程进行总结和图表化,患者公众参与协作贯穿全程。
主要发现
- 共纳入58份转录记录,患者均因症状就诊基层医疗并接受中间非癌诊断。
- 识别出八种涉及初始非癌诊断后转诊疑似癌症的常见情境。
- 低癌症风险个体报告症状被归因于生活方式因素,需多次接触后才考虑进一步检查。
- 当患者感到症状和解释未被充分理解、或接受不适当检查或无效治疗时,会质疑中间诊断。
- 患者认可决定常见症状何时需转诊的难度,但信任对担忧有回应的临床医生,无论结局如何。
临床怎么用
- 全科医生应认识到中间非癌诊断是诊断过程的正常部分,对非特异症状患者保持警惕。
- 面对新证据时应重新审视中间诊断,避免诊断延迟。
- 对患者担忧保持回应性有助于维持信任,即使最终诊断为癌症。
局限性
- 本研究为二次定性分析,原始数据集来自英国基层医疗,结果外推需谨慎。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Background Timely diagnosis of cancer can be challenging as most present with non-specific symptoms in primary care. A third of those diagnosed with cancer report receiving a non-cancer diagnosis, before being referred for cancer investigations ('interim' diagnosis), presenting a potential missed diagnostic opportunity. Aim This study explored patients' experiences of receiving a non-cancer diagnosis prior to referral for investigation for suspected cancer. Design and Setting Secondary qualitative analysis of seven interview datasets collected in primary care in the UK since 2015. Method Patient journeys were summarised, charted and analysed using framework analysis. Patient Public Involvement and Engagement collaborators were involved throughout. Results 58 transcripts were included in which the patient presented to primary care with symptoms and received an interim non-cancer diagnosis. We identified eight common scenarios involving an initial non-cancer diagnosis followed by referral for suspected cancer. For example, individuals considered at low risk of cancer reported symptoms being linked to lifestyle factors, requiring multiple contacts over time before further investigation was considered. Patients queried interim diagnoses when they felt their symptoms and interpretations had been poorly understood, or they had been given inappropriate investigations or ineffective treatment. While patients recognised the difficulty of deciding when common symptoms required onward referral, they trusted clinicians who were responsive to their concerns, regardless of outcome. Conclusion Interim diagnoses arise as part of the normal diagnostic process in patients presenting with non-specific symptoms. Challenging these diagnoses in the face of new evidence could mitigate potential delays in diagnosis and improve patient outcomes.
引用
- Ramasawmy M, Abel GA, Black G, et al. Patient perspectives on the impact of an initial non-cancer diagnosis prior to a subsequent cancer diagnosis: a secondary qualitative analysis. Br J Gen Pract. 2026. PMID: 42538304. doi:10.3399/BJGP.2025.0710
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。