高社会经济剥夺社区中的多病共存与以人为本照护:一项定性研究
本研究在苏格兰高社会经济剥夺社区开展民族志案例研究,通过138小时参与观察、25例多病共存患者深度访谈及焦点小组,探索社区因素如何影响多病共存管理及患者对高质量以人为本照护的定义。研究发现以人为本照护的关键要素包括「患者作为人」「强治疗关系」「照护协调」和「权力共享」,其中权力共享最具赋能性但很少发生。社区共享的「被知晓」「污名」和「系统都不管用」等经历影响患者接触健康服务和决策的方式,高质量以人为本照护可能通过缓解这些负面社区经历而特别有效。
要点
- 以人为本照护的关键要素为「患者作为人」「强治疗关系」「照护协调」和「权力共享」,权力共享最具赋能性但很少发生。
- 社区共享的「被知晓」「污名」和「系统都不管用」经历影响患者接触健康服务和决策。
- 高质量以人为本照护可能通过缓解共享负面社区经历而特别有效,政策制定者应优先并配置资源。
核心结论
- 在高社会经济剥夺环境中,以人为本照护重要且能增强患者参与。
- 更广泛的社区因素对高社会经济剥夺地区患者接触健康照护有关键影响,以人为本照护可能因缓解这些影响而特别重要。
- 政策制定者应优先并配置资源给以人为本照护。
研究设计与样本
- 研究设计为在苏格兰一个高社会经济剥夺社区开展的民族志案例研究。
- 在四个社区团体中进行138小时参与观察,并开展两次参与式工作坊。
- 从当地全科诊所招募多病共存患者进行25次深度访谈,并在一个焦点小组中与受访者讨论初步发现。
- 采用归纳主题分析法分析田野笔记和转录文本。
主要发现
- 以人为本照护的关键方面为「患者作为人」「强治疗关系」「照护协调」和「权力共享」。
- 权力共享特别具有赋能性但很少发生,其障碍常不被从业者察觉。
- 社区共享的「被知晓」「污名」和「系统都不管用」经历影响人们接触健康服务和医疗决策的方式。
- 高质量以人为本照护可能通过缓解更广泛的共享负面社区经历而在此环境中特别有效。
临床怎么用
- 在全科实践中关注并促进权力共享,以增强高社会经济剥夺社区多病共存患者的参与。
- 识别社区共享的「被知晓」「污名」和「系统都不管用」等经历对患者接触健康服务的影响。
- 将高质量以人为本照护作为改善高社会经济剥夺地区多病共存管理的重要策略。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: People with multimorbidity (>2 long-term conditions) have poorer outcomes in areas of high socioeconomic deprivation (SED). High-quality person-centred care (PCC) is important in those with multimorbidity, but socially vulnerable populations have not, to our knowledge, informed current PCC models. AIM: To explore how wider community factors influence management of multimorbidity in the context of high SED, how high-quality PCC is defined by patients, and whether this influences healthcare management. DESIGN AND SETTING: Ethnographically informed case study in a community experiencing high SED in Scotland. METHOD: Participant observation (138 h) was undertaken within four community groups who also took part in two participatory workshops. There were 25 in-depth interviews with people with multimorbidity, recruited from local general practices; emerging findings were discussed with interviewees in one focus group. Field notes/transcripts were analysed using inductive thematic analysis. RESULTS: Key aspects of PCC were 'patient as person', 'strong therapeutic relationship', 'coordination of care', and 'power sharing'; power sharing was particularly enabling but rarely happened (barriers often unseen by practitioners). Shared community experiences of 'being known', 'stigma', and 'none of the systems working' influenced how people approached health services and healthcare decisions. High-quality PCC may have been particularly effective in this setting because of its influence on ameliorating wider shared negative community experiences. CONCLUSION: In a high SED setting PCC is important and can enhance engagement. Wider community factors have a critical influence on engagement with health care in areas of high SED and PCC may be particularly important in this context because of its influence ameliorating these. Policymakers should prioritise and resource PCC.
引用
- McCallum M, Macdonald S, Mair FS, et al. Multimorbidity and person-centred care in a socioeconomically deprived community: a qualitative study. Br J Gen Pract. 2024. PMID: 39438047. doi:10.3399/BJGP.2024.0286
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。