比较基层医疗中管理心血管风险的饮食策略:系统综述的叙述性综述
本文通过叙述性综述比较了六种饮食策略在心血管疾病(CVD)一级预防中的效果。能量缺口、地中海样饮食和盐替代分别使CVD事件相对风险降低30%、40%和30%,但存在一定局限性。减盐、DASH饮食和减少酒精仅小幅降低血压,未减少CVD事件。
要点
- 能量缺口、地中海样饮食和盐替代对CVD事件一级预防有 modest 证据支持。
- 减盐、DASH饮食和减少酒精仅小幅降低血压,未显著减少CVD事件。
- 鱼/鱼油摄入效果甚微,单独鱼油补充仅小幅减少CVD事件。
核心结论
- 对于一级预防,能量缺口、地中海样饮食和钠替代对降低CVD事件风险有 modest 证据。
- 纳入临床营养照护的策略应确保指导以人为中心并针对临床情况量身定制。
研究设计与样本
- 实用主义叙述性综述,聚焦于随机试验的系统综述,针对心血管事件的一级预防。
- 纳入标准:无心血管事件史的成人、旨在降低CVD风险的靶向饮食策略、直接心血管或全因死亡结局。
- 检查六种饮食策略:能量缺口、地中海样饮食、减钠(减盐和盐替代)、DASH饮食、减少酒精、鱼/鱼油摄入。
- 基于质量、时效性和相关性选择综述,使用GRADE评估证据质量和确定性。
主要发现
- 能量缺口显示CVD事件相对风险降低30%(95%CI=13至43)。
- 地中海样饮食显示CVD事件相对风险降低40%(95%CI=20至55)。
- 盐替代显示CVD事件相对风险降低30%(95%CI=7至48)。
- 减盐、DASH饮食和减少酒精显示血压小幅显著降低,但未减少心血管事件。
- 鱼/鱼油摄入显示很小或无效果;单独鱼油补充显示CVD事件小幅减少。
关键数值与推荐
- 能量缺口:CVD事件相对风险降低30%(95%CI=13至43)。
- 地中海样饮食:CVD事件相对风险降低40%(95%CI=20至55)。
- 盐替代:CVD事件相对风险降低30%(95%CI=7至48)。
- 减盐、DASH饮食和减少酒精:血压小幅显著降低,但CVD事件无减少。
- 鱼/鱼油摄入:很小或无效果;单独鱼油补充显示CVD事件小幅减少。
临床怎么用
- 在基层医疗营养照护中,可优先考虑能量缺口、地中海样饮食和盐替代以降低CVD事件风险。
- 提供饮食指导时应以人为中心,并根据患者临床情况量身定制。
局限性
- 这些饮食策略的有效性仍存在一些注意事项。
- 综述未报告具体局限性细节。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Nutrition care in general practice is crucial for cardiovascular disease (CVD) prevention and management, although comparison between dietary strategies is lacking. AIM: To compare the best available (most recent, relevant, and high-quality) evidence for six dietary strategies that are effective for primary prevention/absolute risk reduction of CVD. DESIGN AND SETTING: A pragmatic narrative review of systematic reviews of randomised trials focused on primary prevention of cardiovascular events. METHOD: Studies about: 1) adults without a history of cardiovascular events; 2) target dietary strategies postulated to reduce CVD risk; and 3) direct cardiovascular or all-cause mortality outcomes were included. Six dietary strategies were examined: energy deficit, Mediterranean-like diet, sodium reduction (salt reduction and substitution), the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension (DASH) diet, alcohol reduction, and fish/fish oil consumption. Reviews were selected based on quality, recency, and relevance. Quality and certainty of evidence was assessed using GRADE. RESULTS: Twenty-five reviews met inclusion criteria; eight were selected as the highest quality, recent, and relevant. Three dietary strategies showed modest, significant reductions in cardiovascular events: energy deficit (relative risk reduction [RRR] 30%, 95% confidence interval [CI] = 13 to 43), Mediterranean-like diet (RRR 40%, 95% CI = 20 to 55), and salt substitution (RRR 30%, 95% CI = 7 to 48). Still, some caveats remain on the effectiveness of these dietary strategies. Salt reduction, DASH diet, and alcohol reduction showed small, significant reductions in blood pressure, but no reduction in cardiovascular events. Fish/fish oil consumption showed little or no effect; supplementation of fish oil alone showed small reductions in CVD events. CONCLUSION: For primary prevention, energy deficit, Mediterranean-like diets, and sodium substitution have modest evidence for risk reduction of CVD events. Strategies incorporated into clinical nutrition care should ensure guidance is person centred and tailored to clinical circumstances.
引用
- Greenwood H, Barnes K, Ball L, et al. Comparing dietary strategies to manage cardiovascular risk in primary care: a narrative review of systematic reviews. Br J Gen Pract. 2024. PMID: 38373850. doi:10.3399/BJGP.2022.0564
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。