基层医疗中如何、何时、由谁询问妊娠意愿?女性偏好质性研究
该研究通过对英国13名18-48岁女性进行一对一深度访谈,结合角色扮演和排序练习,探讨在基层医疗中询问妊娠意愿的可接受性。结果显示,女性在理解询问理由、处于相关情境且有后续跟进时,对询问妊娠意愿持开放态度;偏好开放式问题如「未来一年内您对生育孩子有何感受?」并倾向面对面讨论,部分女性偏好数字化方式的隐私与便利。
要点
- 女性对询问妊娠意愿持开放态度需满足:理解理由、情境相关、有后续跟进。
- 面对面时首选开放式提问,如「未来一年内您对生育孩子有何感受?」。
- 部分女性偏好数字化方式的隐私与便利,方法应针对目标人群定制。
核心结论
- 通过多种形式讨论妊娠意愿在英国基层医疗多种情境下对女性可接受且有价值。
- 健康专业人员对询问的可接受性和实施可行性需进一步探索,并需提升公众对妊娠计划益处的认识。
研究设计与样本
- 对英国13名18-48岁女性进行一对一深度访谈,包含角色扮演场景和排序练习。
- 访谈覆盖多种情境和健康专业人员、不同问题措辞及面对面或数字化询问方式。
- 采用主题框架分析法,聚焦与感受和偏好相关的主题。
主要发现
- 女性在理解询问理由、处于相关情境(如女性健康相关咨询)且有后续跟进时,一般对询问妊娠偏好持开放态度。
- 在铺垫后,开放式问题如「未来一年内您对生育孩子有何感受?」在面对面情境中更受偏好,因其便于讨论。
- 部分女性重视与健康专业人员的面对面讨论,另一些女性偏好数字化选项的隐私和便利,方法应针对目标人群定制。
临床怎么用
- 在女性健康相关咨询等情境中,向女性说明询问妊娠意愿的理由后再提问。
- 面对面时优先使用开放式问题,如「未来一年内您对生育孩子有何感受?」以促进讨论。
- 根据目标人群偏好选择面对面或数字化询问方式,并确保有后续跟进。
局限性
- 研究仅纳入13名英国女性,样本量小且限于英国情境。
- 健康专业人员对询问的可接受性和实施可行性未在本研究中探索。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: For health services to help people plan for or prevent pregnancy, health professionals need an acceptable way to identify individuals' preferences. OBJECTIVE: To assess women's views on the acceptability of specific questions about pregnancy preferences when asked by health professionals in a variety of primary care contexts. METHODS: One-to-one in-depth interviews with 13 women aged 18-48 from across the UK, involving role-play scenarios and ranking exercises. Interviews covered a range of settings and health professionals, different question wording, and ways of asking (in person or digitally). We conducted a thematic Framework Analysis, focussing on themes relating to feelings and preferences. RESULTS: Women were generally open to being asked about pregnancy preferences if they understood the rationale, it was asked in a relevant context, such as in women's health-related consultations, and there was follow-up. After signposting, an open question, such as 'How would you feel about having a baby in the next year?' was preferred in a face-to-face context as it enabled discussion. While some women valued a face-to-face discussion with a health professional, for others the privacy and convenience of a digital option was preferred; methods should be tailored to the target population. CONCLUSION: Discussion of pregnancy preferences via a range of formats is acceptable to, and valued by, women in the UK across a range of primary care settings. Acceptability to health professionals and feasibility of implementation needs further exploration and would benefit from greater public awareness of the benefits of pregnancy planning.
引用
- Hall JA, Wilkinson K, Haddon C, et al. How, when, and who should ask about pregnancy intentions in primary care? A qualitative study of women's preferences. Fam Pract. 2024. PMID: 38124485. doi:10.1093/fampra/cmad114
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。