英国全科诊所昆虫叮咬是否导致夏季氟氯西林处方增加?
一项在英国和威尔士10家全科诊所开展的质量改进研究,调查2021年4–9月首次因昆虫叮咬就诊的患者,记录就诊方式、表现、处理及转归,并比较诊所总氟氯西林处方与昆虫叮咬相关处方。结果显示昆虫叮咬 consultations 中近四分之三被处方抗生素(主要为口服氟氯西林),而昆虫叮咬相关氟氯西林平均占诊所总氟氯西林处方的5.1%,7月峰值达10.7%。作者认为抗生素可能被过度使用,患者就诊前可更多使用抗组胺药止痒。
要点
- 昆虫叮咬 consultations 中近四分之三被处方抗生素,主要为口服氟氯西林。
- 昆虫叮咬相关氟氯西林平均占诊所总氟氯西林处方的5.1%,7月峰值10.7%。
- 仅22%患者就诊前已使用抗组胺药,尽管45%主诉瘙痒。
核心结论
- 全科诊所昆虫叮咬诊疗中抗生素可能被过度使用,患者就诊前可更多使用抗组胺药缓解瘙痒。
研究设计与样本
- 质量改进研究,纳入英格兰和威尔士10家全科诊所2021年4–9月首次因昆虫叮咬就诊的患者,记录就诊方式、表现、处理计划及再就诊或转诊,并比较诊所总氟氯西林处方与昆虫叮咬相关处方。
主要发现
- 合并名单161,346人,共355次昆虫叮咬就诊,近三分之二为女性,年龄3–89岁,7月为高峰月,平均周发病率8/10万。
- 多数由全科医生接诊,多数为电话咨询,超过一半有照片支持;超过40%在发病第1–3天就诊,常见症状为发红、瘙痒、疼痛和发热。
- 生命体征记录不常见,仅22%患者已在使用抗组胺药,尽管45%主诉瘙痒。
- 近四分之三患者被处方抗生素,主要为口服且多为氟氯西林;再就诊率12%,转诊医院率2%。
- 昆虫叮咬相关氟氯西林平均占诊所总氟氯西林处方的5.1%,7月峰值10.7%。
关键数值与推荐
- 昆虫叮咬 consultations 中近四分之三被处方抗生素,主要为口服氟氯西林。
- 昆虫叮咬相关氟氯西林平均占诊所总氟氯西林处方的5.1%,7月峰值10.7%。
- 仅22%患者已在使用抗组胺药,45%主诉瘙痒;再就诊率12%,转诊医院率2%。
临床怎么用
- 全科医生应意识到昆虫叮咬炎症可能类似蜂窝织炎,避免不必要的抗生素处方。
- 对于昆虫叮咬瘙痒,可建议患者先使用抗组胺药(必要时联用类固醇药膏)再就诊。
- 需建立研究验证疼痛缓解、抗组胺药和类固醇药膏等家庭管理能否减少抗生素使用。
局限性
- 原文未报告局限性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Insect bite inflammation may mimic cellulitis and promote unnecessary antibiotic usage, contributing to antimicrobial resistance in primary care. We wondered how general practice clinicians assess and manage insect bites, diagnose cellulitis, and prescribe antibiotics. METHOD: This is a Quality Improvement study in which 10 general practices in England and Wales investigated patients attending for the first time with insect bites between April and September 2021 to their practices. Mode of consultation, presentation, management plan, and reattendance or referral were noted. Total practice flucloxacillin prescribing was compared to that for insect bites. RESULTS: A combined list size of 161,346 yielded 355 insect bite consultations. Nearly two-thirds were female, ages 3-89 years old, with July as the peak month and a mean weekly incidence of 8 per 100,000. GPs still undertook most consultations; most were phone consultations, with photo support for over half. Over 40% presented between days 1 and 3 and common symptoms were redness, itchness, pain, and heat. Vital sign recording was not common, and only 22% of patients were already taking an antihistamine despite 45% complaining of itch. Antibiotics were prescribed to nearly three-quarters of the patients, mainly orally and mostly as flucloxacillin. Reattendance occurred for 12% and referral to hospital for 2%. Flucloxacillin for insect bites contributed a mean of 5.1% of total practice flucloxacillin prescriptions, with a peak of 10.7% in July. CONCLUSIONS: Antibiotics are likely to be overused in our insect bite practice and patients could make more use of antihistamines for itch before consulting. It can be difficult to know if redness, heat, swelling, and pain from insect bites are due to inflammation or infection. Prescribing unnecessary antibiotics may result in germs becoming resistant to antibiotics when needed. Ten general practices in England and Wales investigated their management of insect bites in the 6 months of April to September 2021 inclusive. There were 355 bites; women presented more often than men, and ages were from 3 to 89 years old, half of them were 30–69 years old. People mainly consulted their GP by phone with photos of their bites. Key symptoms were redness, itchness, heat, and pain. More people had itch than were taking antihistamines or using steroid cream. Most people (nearly 7 out of 10) were prescribed an oral antibiotic, usually flucloxacillin, which accounted for about 5% of total flucloxacillin prescribed in the practices. Only 2 in 100 people needed further hospital care. It is likely that general practice clinicians are over-using antibiotics for insect bites and that home management before seeking medical help with painkillers, antihistamines, and steroid creams could be used more. Now that we have baseline data, there is a need to set up studies to prove that these reduce antibiotic usage.
引用
- Wilcock J, Hawthorne K, Reeve J, et al. Are insect bites responsible for the rise in summer flucloxacillin prescribing in United Kingdom general practices? Fam Pract. 2023. PMID: 37148202. doi:10.1093/fampra/cmad051
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。