指南与共识儿童保健慢病管理

儿童哮喘指南质量:诊断检测推荐背后的证据

The quality of paediatric asthma guidelines: evidence underpinning diagnostic test recommendations from a meta-epidemiological study.
指南 / 共识 · Fam Pract · 2024-01-01

结果显示指南方法学与报告质量参差(AGREE-II中位4.5/7,范围2-6),支持诊断推荐的证据总体质量极低,所有指南推荐≥5岁儿童用肺量计与可逆性检测但阈值不一,7项检测中3项推荐不一致。

要点

  • 支持诊断检测推荐的证据质量总体极低。
  • ≥5岁儿童肺量计与可逆性检测被普遍推荐,但诊断阈值各指南不一致。

核心结论

  • 指南质量参差、缺乏高质量证据及检测推荐不一致,可能造成临床医生依从性差和儿童哮喘诊断检测的差异。

研究设计与样本

  • 元流行病学研究,纳入英国及其他高收入国家、初级保健体系可比的英文指南,且须包含儿童哮喘初级保健诊断检测推荐。
  • 采用AGREE-II工具评估指南质量与报告,采用GRADE评估证据质量。

主要发现

  • AGREE-II各领域方法学与报告质量中位得分4.5分(满分7分,范围2-6)。
  • 支持诊断推荐的证据质量总体为极低质量。
  • 所有指南均推荐≥5岁儿童使用肺量计与可逆性检测,但推荐的肺量计诊断阈值各指南不同。
  • 7项纳入检测中有3项的推荐存在分歧。

关键数值与推荐

  • 所有指南推荐≥5岁儿童行肺量计与可逆性检测,但各指南推荐的肺量计诊断阈值不一致。
  • 7项纳入检测中3项的检测推荐存在分歧。
  • AGREE-II中位得分4.5/7(范围2-6),支持诊断推荐的证据总体为极低质量。

临床怎么用

  • 全科医生参考儿童哮喘诊断指南时应留意其方法学质量与证据强度有限。
  • 对≥5岁儿童,肺量计与可逆性检测虽被普遍推荐,但阈值不统一,解读需谨慎。
  • 检测选择上的指南分歧提示临床决策需结合具体情况,不宜机械照搬单一指南。

局限性

  • 仅纳入英文指南,且限于英国及其他高收入国家可比初级保健体系。
  • 原文未报告各指南具体名称、发表年份及证据分级细节。
  • 原文未报告指南间诊断阈值差异的具体数值及推荐分歧的具体检测项目。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

BACKGROUND: Asthma is one of the most frequent reasons children visit a general practitioner (GP). The diagnosis of childhood asthma is challenging, and a variety of diagnostic tests for asthma exist. GPs may refer to clinical practice guidelines when deciding which tests, if any, are appropriate, but the quality of these guidelines is unknown. OBJECTIVES: To determine (i) the methodological quality and reporting of paediatric guidelines for the diagnosis of childhood asthma in primary care, and (ii) the strength of evidence supporting diagnostic test recommendations. DESIGN: Meta-epidemiological study of English-language guidelines from the United Kingdom and other high-income countries with comparable primary care systems including diagnostic testing recommendations for childhood asthma in primary care. The AGREE-II tool was used to assess the quality and reporting of the guidelines. The quality of the evidence was assessed using GRADE. RESULTS: Eleven guidelines met the eligibility criteria. The methodology and reporting quality varied across the AGREE II domains (median score 4.5 out of 7, range 2-6). The quality of evidence supporting diagnostic recommendations was generally of very low quality. All guidelines recommended the use of spirometry and reversibility testing for children aged ≥5 years, however, the recommended spirometry thresholds for diagnosis differed across guidelines. There were disagreements in testing recommendations for 3 of the 7 included tests. CONCLUSIONS: The variable quality of guidelines, lack of good quality evidence, and inconsistent recommendations for diagnostic tests may contribute to poor clinician adherence to guidelines and variation in testing for diagnosing childhood asthma.

来源:Fam Pract,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Thomas ET, Thomas ST, Perera R, et al. The quality of paediatric asthma guidelines: evidence underpinning diagnostic test recommendations from a meta-epidemiological study. Fam Pract. 2024. PMID: 37196169. doi:10.1093/fampra/cmad052

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。