文献速递慢病管理基层心理健康预防保健、筛查与疫苗

苏格兰撤销基层医疗财务激励对部分医疗质量指标的影响:对照中断时间序列分析

Estimated impact from the withdrawal of primary care financial incentives on selected indicators of quality of care in Scotland: controlled interrupted time series analysis.
PubMed 文献 · BMJ · 2023-03-22

该研究采用对照中断时间序列回归分析,比较苏格兰2016年撤销质量与结果框架(QOF)财务激励后与继续实施该框架的英格兰在16项医疗质量指标上的变化。结果显示,撤销后1年12项指标、3年10项指标在苏格兰显著下降,其中精神卫生保健计划记录和糖尿病足筛查下降幅度最大,但流感免疫及冠心病抗血小板/抗凝治疗无显著差异。

要点

  • 苏格兰撤销QOF后3年,精神卫生保健计划记录率较英格兰低40.2个百分点(95%CI -45.5至-35.0)。
  • 糖尿病足筛查率下降22.8个百分点(95%CI -33.9至-11.7),外周动脉疾病血压控制下降18.5个百分点。
  • 流感免疫及冠心病抗血小板/抗凝治疗在撤销3年后无显著差异。

核心结论

  • 苏格兰撤销基层医疗财务激励与多数质量指标记录质量下降相关,提示绩效付费改革需谨慎设计并监测质量变化。

研究设计与样本

  • 对照中断时间序列回归分析,比较苏格兰与英格兰全科诊所2013-14至2018-19财年16项质量指标的年均变化。
  • 苏格兰2013-14年有979家诊所、5 599 171名注册患者,2018-19年降至864家;英格兰同期从7921家、56 270 628名患者降至6873家。

主要发现

  • 撤销QOF后1年,苏格兰16项指标中12项较英格兰显著下降;3年时10项显著下降。
  • 3年时绝对百分点差异最大为精神卫生保健计划记录(-40.2,95%CI -45.5至-35.0)和糖尿病足筛查(-22.8,95%CI -33.9至-11.7)。
  • 中间结局亦显著下降:外周动脉疾病血压控制(-18.5,95%CI -22.1至-14.9)、卒中或短暂性脑缺血发作(-16.6,95%CI -20.6至-12.7)、高血压(-13.7,95%CI -19.4至-7.9)、糖尿病(-12.7,95%CI -15.0至-12.4)、冠心病(-12.8,95%CI -14.9至-10.8)。
  • HbA1c≤75 mmol/mol者血糖控制下降(-5.0,95%CI -8.4至-1.5)。
  • 撤销3年后流感免疫及冠心病抗血小板或抗凝治疗在苏格兰与英格兰间无显著差异。

关键数值与推荐

  • 共评估16项指标:2项复杂流程、9项中间结局、5项治疗,按财年2013-14至2018-19每年测量。
  • 以英格兰为对照,比较苏格兰撤销QOF财务激励后1年和3年的指标变化。

临床怎么用

  • 全科医生应关注撤销绩效激励后精神卫生保健计划记录、糖尿病足筛查及慢病中间结局监测可能出现的质量下滑。
  • 对绩效付费政策调整需建立持续质量监测与反馈机制,及时应对记录和治疗质量下降。

局限性

  • 观察性设计不能完全排除未测量混杂因素对苏格兰与英格兰差异的影响。
  • 诊所数量因合并减少,可能影响结果外推。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

OBJECTIVE: To determine whether the withdrawal of the Quality and Outcomes Framework (QOF) scheme in primary care in Scotland in 2016 had an impact on selected recorded quality of care, compared with England where the scheme continued. DESIGN: Controlled interrupted time series regression analysis. SETTING: General practices in Scotland and England. PARTICIPANTS: 979 practices with 5 599 171 registered patients in Scotland, and 7921 practices with 56 270 628 registered patients in England in 2013-14, decreasing to 864 practices in Scotland and 6873 in England in 2018-19, mainly due to practice mergers. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Changes in quality of care at one year and three years after withdrawal of QOF financial incentives in Scotland at the end of the 2015-16 financial year for 16 indicators (two complex processes, nine intermediate outcomes, and five treatments) measured annually for financial years from 2013-14 to 2018-19. RESULTS: A significant decrease in performance was observed for 12 of the 16 quality of care indicators in Scotland one year after QOF was abolished and for 10 of the 16 indicators three years after QOF was abolished, compared with England. At three years, the absolute percentage point difference between Scotland and England was largest for recording (by tick box) of mental health care planning (-40.2 percentage points, 95% confidence interval -45.5 to -35.0) and diabetic foot screening (-22.8, -33.9 to -11.7). Substantial reductions were, however, also observed for intermediate outcomes, including blood pressure control in patients with peripheral arterial disease (-18.5, -22.1 to -14.9), stroke or transient ischaemic attack (-16.6, -20.6 to -12.7), hypertension (-13.7, -19.4 to -7.9), diabetes (-12.7, -15.0 to -12.4), or coronary heart disease (-12.8, -14.9 to -10.8), and for glycated haemoglobin control in people with HbA1c levels ≤75 mmol/mol (-5.0, -8.4 to -1.5). No significant differences were observed between Scotland and England for influenza immunisation and antiplatelet or anticoagulant treatment for coronary heart disease three years after withdrawal of incentives. CONCLUSION: The abolition of financial incentives in Scotland was associated with reductions in recorded quality of care for most performance indicators. Changes to pay for performance should be carefully designed and implemented to monitor and respond to any reductions in care quality.

来源:BMJ,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Morales DR, Minchin M, Kontopantelis E, et al. Estimated impact from the withdrawal of primary care financial incentives on selected indicators of quality of care in Scotland: controlled interrupted time series analysis. BMJ. 2023. PMID: 36948515. doi:10.1136/bmj-2022-072098

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。