患者对糖尿病共享医疗预约在COVID-19疫情前后的看法
患者认为SMA有益,最看重营养内容和社交获益,教学风格对满意度很重要,虚拟形式可接受。
要点
- 患者最偏好营养等经典糖尿病自我管理话题,心理健康和技能建设内容评价不一但总体有价值。
- SMA的社交方面被视为最大获益,但同伴导师角色(仅患者驱动模式)并非总被认可。
- 引导者教学风格对满意度贡献很大,所有患者都希望有不同专长的客座讲者。
核心结论
- 患者认为SMA有益,偏好经典糖尿病自我管理话题甚于心理健康和技能建设,教学风格对满意度非常重要,虚拟形式可接受。
主要发现
- 新诊断和长期糖尿病患者均认为课程有用,患者普遍喜欢课程内容,营养最受青睐。
- SMA的社交方面被视为最大获益,但同伴导师角色(仅患者驱动模式)并非总被认可。
- 患者选择话题顺序和行为健康作为照护团队一部分(仅患者驱动模式)被视为有帮助但非必需,客座讲者受到所有人支持。
- 引导者大多被视为支持性且教学风格令人愉快,对积极体验贡献很大;虚拟SMA参与者大多持正面看法,但有些人仍偏好面授课程。
临床怎么用
- 在基层糖尿病管理中可优先安排营养等经典自我管理话题,并重视引导者教学风格以提升患者满意度。
- 虚拟SMA形式可作为面授课程的补充,方便繁忙患者参与并维持疫情期间的照护连续性。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Context: Shared Medical Appointments for diabetes (SMAs) are an evidence-based strategy improve health outcomes. However, which elements of SMAs are important remain unknown. Invested in Diabetes studied two implementation approaches (standardized [STD] vs. patient-driven [PTD]), using a curriculum focused on mental health and skill building in addition to diabetes self-management. Objective: To understand patient experiences and preferences, including care team and peer mentor involvement, and how teaching style affected satisfaction. Those completing SMAs after the COVID pandemic began discussed their experience with virtual SMAs. Study Design: Semi-structured interviews, conducted between 2019-21. Setting: 21 primary care practices in Colorado and Kansas. Population: Patients with type 2 diabetes who attended SMAs at participating sites. Outcome Measures: Transcripts were analyzed using qualitative thematic analysis (data triangulation and a constant comparative technique). Results: Forty-one patients from 14 participating clinics agreed to participate (25 STD, 16 PTD). All patients completed their 6-class cohort. Both newly diagnosed patients and those living with diabetes for longer found classes useful. Patients generally enjoyed the content, with nutrition favored most. Opinion on mental health topics and skill building varied, but overall deemed valuable. The social aspect of SMAs was seen as the biggest benefit. However, the peer mentor role (PTD only) was not always appreciated. Patient topic order selection and behavioral health as part of the care team (PTD only) were viewed as helpful but not necessary, though guest lecturers were supported by all. Facilitators were mostly seen as supportive and their teaching style agreeable, which contributed considerably to positive experiences. Those who did virtual SMAs had mostly positive views. The format allowed continuation of care that may have been halted due to the pandemic, let people with busy schedules to participate, and in some instances made sharing easier to do. Some would still have preferred an in-person class. Conclusions: Patients found SMAs beneficial, favoring classic diabetes self-management topics over mental health and skill building. The peer mentor role was not always well received, likely due to variations in the peer mentor. Teaching style was very important to satisfaction, and all patients wanted guest speakers with varied expertise. A virtual format was acceptable. .
引用
- Gurfinkel D, Waxmonsky J, Summers Holtrop J, et al. Patient perspectives on diabetes shared medical appointments before, during, and after the COVID-19 pandemic. Ann Fam Med. 2022. PMID: 36857158. doi:10.1370/afm.20.s1.3011
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。