将证据付诸实践:美国预防服务工作组制定预防服务推荐方法的更新
本文总结美国预防服务工作组(USPSTF)当前制定预防服务推荐的方法,并描述方法如何演进以应对预防健康公平,同时界定未来研究的证据缺口。USPSTF基于疾病负担、新证据范围及服务能否在基层提供来优先选题,并将日益考虑健康公平。
要点
- USPSTF根据疾病负担、新证据范围及基层可提供性优先选题。
- USPSTF对净获益的确定性分级为高、中、低,并判断净获益 magnitude。
- USPSTF将证据不足的情况发布为I声明。
核心结论
- USPSTF将继续演进模拟建模方法,并利用证据应对疾病负担不成比例人群数据有限的状况。
- 正在开展试点工作以更好理解种族、族裔和性别等社会建构与健康结局的关系,为制定USPSTF健康公平框架提供信息。
研究设计与样本
- 本文总结USPSTF当前方法及正在开展的方法学开发。
主要发现
- USPSTF基于疾病负担、新证据范围及服务能否在基层提供来优先选题,并将日益考虑健康公平。
- 分析框架明确关键问题及预防服务与健康结局之间的关联。
- 背景问题提供自然史、当前实践、高风险群体健康结局及健康公平的信息。
- USPSTF对预防服务净获益估计赋予确定性水平(高、中、低),并判断净获益大小(substantial、moderate、small或zero/negative)。
- USPSTF使用这些评估赋予字母等级A(推荐)至D(不推荐),证据不足时发布I声明。
关键数值与推荐
- USPSTF净获益确定性水平分为高、中、低。
- USPSTF净获益大小判断为substantial、moderate、small或zero/negative。
- USPSTF字母等级从A(推荐)至D(不推荐),证据不足时发布I声明。
临床怎么用
- 全科医生可依据USPSTF的A至D等级及I声明理解预防服务推荐强度与证据确定性。
- USPSTF选题日益考虑健康公平,提示基层实践关注疾病负担不成比例人群的预防服务证据缺口。
局限性
- 原文未报告USPSTF方法的具体样本量、检索范围或验证数据。
- 健康公平框架尚在试点开发中,相关方法学尚未定稿。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
PURPOSE: The US Preventive Services Task Force (USPSTF) is an independent body that makes evidence-based recommendations regarding preventive services to improve health for people nationwide. Here, we summarize current USPSTF methods, describe how methods are evolving to address preventive health equity, and define evidence gaps for future research. METHODS: We summarize current USPSTF methods as well as ongoing methods development. RESULTS: The USPSTF prioritizes topics on the basis of disease burden, extent of new evidence, and whether the service can be provided in primary care and going forward will increasingly consider health equity. Analytic frameworks specify the key questions and linkages connecting the preventive service to health outcomes. Contextual questions provide information on natural history, current practice, health outcomes in high-risk groups, and health equity. The USPSTF assigns a level of certainty to the estimate of net benefit of a preventive service (high, moderate, or low). The magnitude of net benefit is also judged (substantial, moderate, small, or zero/negative). The USPSTF uses these assessments to assign a letter grade from A (recommend) to D (recommend against). I statements are issued when evidence is insufficient. CONCLUSIONS: The USPSTF will continue to evolve its methods for simulation modeling and to use evidence to address conditions for which there are limited data for population groups who bear a disproportionate burden of disease. Additional pilot work is underway to better understand the relations of the social constructs of race, ethnicity, and gender with health outcomes to inform the development of a USPSTF health equity framework.
引用
- Barry MJ, Wolff TA, Pbert L, et al. Putting Evidence Into Practice: An Update on the US Preventive Services Task Force Methods for Developing Recommendations for Preventive Services. Ann Fam Med. 2023. PMID: 36973047. doi:10.1370/afm.2946
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。