审计与反馈循环改善对加拿大明智选择建议依从性的随机对照试验
该集群随机对照试验在曼尼托巴初级保健研究网络中评估审计与反馈干预对减少不必要抗生素和抗精神病药处方的影响。182名初级保健提供者被随机分为三组:仅CWC建议信息、实践特异性数据加一般信息、无CWC信息。结果显示,干预组减少目标处方的比例显著高于对照组,且实践特异性反馈与一般信息之间无显著差异。
要点
- 审计与反馈干预可减少初级保健中不必要抗生素和抗精神病药处方。
- 实践特异性反馈与一般CWC信息在减少处方上无显著差异。
- 干预效果在2016/17至2018/19年间保持稳定。
核心结论
- 直接由可信来源发送实践特异性或一般性审计与反馈信息均可减少初级保健中潜在不必要的处方。
研究设计与样本
- 集群随机对照试验,数据来自曼尼托巴初级保健研究网络,包含超过288,000名曼尼托巴人的去标识化电子病历数据。
- 182名初级保健提供者被随机分为三组:仅CWC建议信息、实践特异性数据加一般信息、无CWC信息。
主要发现
- 86.3%的提供者减少了目标处方数量。
- 组1(88.9%)和组2(94.0%)减少处方的提供者比例高于对照组3(76.7%),P值为0.02。
- 实践特异性反馈与一般CWC信息之间无统计学显著差异。
- 2014/2015年平均每位提供者因病毒指征开具46种抗生素,2016/17年降至15种,2018/19年为18种。
- 2014/2015年平均每位提供者为痴呆患者开具3种抗精神病药,2016/17年下降7%,2018/19年保持稳定。
关键数值与推荐
- 组1减少处方比例88.9%,组2为94.0%,对照组3为76.7%,P=0.02。
- 2014/2015年病毒指征抗生素平均处方46种/提供者,2016/17年15种,2018/19年18种。
- 2014/2015年痴呆患者抗精神病药平均处方3种/提供者,2016/17年下降7%,2018/19年稳定。
临床怎么用
- 初级保健提供者可接受审计与反馈干预以减少不必要处方。
- 实践特异性反馈与一般CWC信息均可作为改善处方的有效策略。
局限性
- 未报告提供者特征在所有改善处方的提供者中无统计学显著差异,但男性、农村和按服务收费的提供者更可能超过平均减少幅度。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Context: Choosing Wisely Canada (CWC) aims to engage healthcare providers to reduce unnecessary care. Reducing overuse of antimicrobials and antipsychotics in patients with dementia in primary care settings remains an ongoing challenge. Audit and Feedback (A&F) interventions can facilitate practice change but can be improved by understanding factors affecting the likelihood of uptake of the feedback. Objective: To assess the impact of A&F interventions to reduce unnecessary prescribing of antibiotics and antipsychotics use and evaluate whether practice changes remain stable over time. Design: Clustered randomized controlled trial. Dataset: The Manitoba Primary Care Research Network (MaPCReN), a practice-based network that includes a repository containing de-identified EMR data from over 288,000 Manitobans. Population: Primary care providers participating in MaPCReN were randomized to three A&F groups: 1) Information on the relevant CWC recommendations; 2) practice specific data along with general information regarding the CWC recommendations 3) No CWC information. Outcome Measures: Statistics demonstrating changes in target prescriptions. Multivariate regression assessed characteristics of providers with improved prescribing. Results: 182 primary care providers were evaluated, 86.3% decreased the number of target prescriptions. More providers decreased prescribing in group1 (88.9%) or group2 (94.0%) compared to the control group 3 (76.7%) (p-value 0.02). There was no statistically significant difference between practice specific feedback and generic CWC information. An average of 46 antibiotic medications per provider were prescribed for viral indications in 2014/2015. This dropped to 15 in 2016/17 and was 18 in 2018/19. An average of 3 antipsychotic medications were prescribed for patients with dementia in 2014/2015. This dropped 7% in 2016/17 and remained stable in 2018/19. There were no statistically significant provider characteristics when considering all providers with improved prescribing, but male, rural and fee for service providers were more likely to decrease prescribing greater than the mean. Conclusion: Both practice specific and generic A&F information sent directly to primary care providers by a trusted source reduced potentially unnecessary prescriptions. This supports ongoing engagement with primary care providers in practice-based research networks to improve care and promote sustained practice changes.
引用
- Singer A, Kosowan L, Leong K, et al. Randomized controlled trial of an audit and feedback cycle to improve adherence to Choosing Wisely Canada recommendations. Ann Fam Med. 2022. PMID: 36857209. doi:10.1370/afm.20.s1.2883
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。