共享决策研究与实践中黑美国患者的差异:以黑美国患者为例
该研究通过访谈32名在安全网初级保健机构接受2型糖尿病诊疗的黑美国患者,探讨其对共享决策(SDM)的偏好、需求与挑战。研究发现四个主题:偏好人性化沟通、需考虑家庭在决策中的作用、需要医疗信息共享、对临床医生的不信任。结论建议采用故事讲述策略、三元SDM并重新审视现有SDM模型的普适性假设。
要点
- 黑患者偏好人性化沟通及故事讲述以赋予医疗信息意义。
- 家庭应核心参与决策,三元SDM优于经典二元SDM。
- 患者对临床医生存在不信任,需加强信息共享。
核心结论
- 需重新考虑当代SDM模型的普适性假设及当前SDM实践的相关性,这些实践多未纳入少数族裔反馈。
研究设计与样本
- 对32名在主要服务黑人的安全网初级保健机构接受2型糖尿病诊疗的黑美国患者进行访谈。
主要发现
- 出现四个主题:偏好人性化沟通、需考虑家庭在决策中的作用、需要医疗信息共享、对临床医生不信任。
临床怎么用
- 建议采用故事讲述策略将医疗信息置于有意义且易记忆的背景中。
- 推荐三元SDM,让家庭成员核心参与决策,而非经典二元SDM。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
OBJECTIVE: The extent of shared decision making (SDM) use in the care of Black patients is limited. We explored preferences, needs, and challenges of Black patients to enhance SDM offerings. METHODS: We performed interviews with 32 Black patients receiving type 2 diabetes care in safety-net primary care practices caring predominantly for Black people. RESULTS: The following 4 themes emerged: preference for humanistic communication, need to account for the role of family in decision making, need for medical information sharing, and mistrust of clinicians. CONCLUSION: Given the dearth of research on SDM among ethnic and racial minorities, this study offers patient-perspective recommendations to improve SDM offerings for Black patients in primary care settings. To enhance SDM with Black patients, acknowledgment of the importance of storytelling as a strategy, to place medical information in a context that makes it meaningful and memorable, is recommended. Triadic SDM, in which family members are centrally involved in decision making, is preferred over classical dyadic SDM. There is a need to reconsider the universalism assumption underlying contemporary SDM models and the relevancy of current SDM practices that were developed mostly without the feedback of participants of ethnic, racial, and cultural minorities.Annals "Online First" article.
引用
- Zisman-Ilani Y, Khaikin S, Savoy ML, et al. Disparities in Shared Decision-Making Research and Practice: The Case for Black American Patients. Ann Fam Med. 2023. PMID: 36750357. doi:10.1370/afm.2943
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。