文献速递慢病管理预防保健、筛查与疫苗老年与多病共存

加拿大安大略省伦敦-米德尔塞克斯地区家庭医生在COVID-19期间的虚拟照护:一项混合方法探索

Family physician virtual care during COVID-19 in London-Middlesex, Ontario, Canada: a mixed methods exploration.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Fam Med · 2022-04-01

该研究采用混合方法,分析健康行政数据并对家庭医生进行半结构化访谈,旨在明确虚拟就诊量及患者特征,并探讨家庭医生对虚拟照护采纳与实施的看法。结果显示,第一波疫情期间总就诊量下降36%,面对面就诊锐减73%,虚拟就诊在两周内从0.08%升至57%;家庭医生认为脆弱患者获得了照护,但无家可归者及农村居民存在接入障碍。

要点

  • 面对面就诊下降73%,虚拟就诊两周内从0.08%升至57%,以电话为主。
  • 家庭医生担忧无家可归者缺乏手机或安全通话环境,农村地区缺乏高速网络。

核心结论

  • 家庭医生迅速转向虚拟照护,诊所虽保持开放但初期总就诊量下降,脆弱和病情较重患者获得了照护,但家庭医生对高度脆弱人群和农村居民表示担忧。

研究设计与样本

  • 混合方法研究:基于ICES健康行政数据的二次分析,结合对家庭医生的半结构化定性访谈,地点为加拿大安大略省伦敦和米德尔塞克斯县。

主要发现

  • 与疫情前相比,就诊患者更年长(46岁 vs 50岁)、更脆弱(38% vs 41%)、多病共存更多(33% vs 41%)。
  • 家庭医生将虚拟照护的成功归因于疫情前面对面建立的患者关系连续性;他们认为多数脆弱患者能获得照护,但高度脆弱者如无家可归者缺乏手机或安全通话场所,农村家庭医生报告因缺乏高速网络存在接入问题。
  • 家庭医生认为可通过电话提供以患者为中心的照护,但指出维持面对面照护对建立关系很重要;初期就诊量下降被描述为患者不寻求照护及诊所缺乏个人防护装备。

临床怎么用

  • 在公共卫生危机中可快速启用电话为主的虚拟照护,但需关注高度脆弱人群(如无家可归者)和农村居民的接入障碍。
  • 虚拟照护可依托既有医患关系连续性提供以患者为中心的照护,但仍需保留面对面照护以建立关系。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Context: On March 14, 2020, the Ontario, Canada health insurance plan approved COVID-19 physician virtual billing codes; family physicians (FPs) rapidly adopted a new model of care. Virtual care may remain post-pandemic; however, its future should be informed by evidence that considers access and continuity. Objective: 1) to determine FP virtual visit volumes and patient characteristics and 2) to explore FPs' perspectives on virtual visit adoption and implementation. Study Design: Mixed methods: Secondary analysis of health administrative (HA) data and semi-structured qualitative interviews with FPs. Setting or Dataset: London and Middlesex County, Ontario, Canada. HA data through ICES, Ontario entity holding data. Population studied: FPs and their patients. Outcome Measures: Volumes of FP in-person and virtual visits during early pandemic; characteristics of patients receiving care; FPs' perspectives on adopting and delivering virtual care. Results: Overall visit volume dropped by 36% during first wave, recovered to pre-pandemic levels by October 2020. Sharp in-person visit drop of 73% and virtual visit uptake from 0.08% of total visits to 57% within two weeks of March 2020. FPs described this initial drop in volume as patients not seeking care and practices lacking PPE. The move to virtual care was largely to telephone visits. Patient characteristics compared to pre-pandemic, the proportion seeking care were older (46 vs 50 years), more vulnerable (38% vs 41%), and more multimorbidity (33% vs 41%). This was consistent with FP reports that healthier patients stayed away, routine care deferred, sicker patients needed to be seen. FPs believed most vulnerable patients had access to care but cautioned highly vulnerable such as those homeless did not have cell phone access or a safe place to receive calls. Rural FPs reported access issues because of lack of high-speed internet. FPs attributed success of virtual care to the continuity in relationships they had with patients that were established in person pre-pandemic. Conclusions: FPs moved rapidly to virtual care. FP offices remained open despite PPE concerns but overall volumes dropped initially. Vulnerable and sicker patients received care but FPs expressed concern for highly vulnerable and rural residents. FPs believed they could offer patient-centred care over the phone but indicated the importance of maintaining in-person care to build relationships.

来源:Ann Fam Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. Ryan B, Thompson K, Meredith L, et al. Family physician virtual care during COVID-19 in London-Middlesex, Ontario, Canada: a mixed methods exploration. Ann Fam Med. 2022. PMID: 36706041. doi:10.1370/afm.20.s1.2863

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。