疫情反思:需要重大变革以发挥基层医疗在危机中的作用
本研究通过2021年4-5月对加拿大全科医生(FP)的在线自报调查(邀请39,991人,回复3,409人,应答率9%),评估基层医疗参与COVID-19应对措施的程度及相关因素。结果显示仅34%的FP报告其地区家庭诊所向公共卫生部门报告COVID-19病例,55%未被要求识别优先接种疫苗患者,19%参与顾问/规划委员会,6%参与研究,50%对政府缺乏明确FP应对指导高度担忧。结论认为加拿大基层医疗系统未充分参与关键疫情应对措施,实践模式与报酬安排影响响应性。
要点
- 仅34%的FP报告其地区家庭诊所向公共卫生部门报告COVID-19病例。
- 55%的FP未被要求识别COVID-19疫苗接种优先病例,19%参与疫情顾问/规划委员会。
- 50%的FP对政府缺乏明确FP应对疫情指导高度担忧,仅6%参与COVID-19研究。
核心结论
- 加拿大基层医疗系统未充分参与COVID-19关键应对措施,包括监测病毒传播、疫情规划、疫苗接种推进及治疗研究。
- 实践模式和报酬安排与基层医疗对COVID-19疫情的响应性相关,应在未来基层医疗系统发展中予以考虑。
研究设计与样本
- 在线自报调查,于2021年4月至5月进行,为期3周,通过电子邮件发送邀请并三次提醒。
- 使用加拿大全科医师学院(CFPC)会员名单,邀请所有活跃FP会员,39,991名FP收到邀请,3,409名回复,总体应答率9%。
主要发现
- 34%的FP表示其地区家庭诊所向公共卫生当局报告COVID-19病例。
- 55%的FP表示其诊所未被要求识别COVID-19疫苗接种优先病例。
- 19%的FP参与了COVID-19顾问/规划委员会、工作组或小组。
- 6%的FP参与COVID-19研究/临床研究。
- 50%的FP对政府关于FP应对疫情缺乏明确性高度担忧,这些发现因地区和执业/报酬模式而异。
临床怎么用
- 基层医疗在疫情应对中应更主动参与公共卫生监测、疫苗接种优先识别和疫情规划。
- 未来基层医疗系统发展需考虑实践模式和报酬安排对响应性的影响。
局限性
- 应答率仅9%,可能存在无应答偏倚。
- 为自报调查,结果可能受回忆偏倚或社会期望偏倚影响。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Context: As a front-line resource, primary care could function as an indispensable health system resource during pandemic crises. However, throughout COVID-19, Canada's primary care providers expressed concern over their ability to respond. This study investigates factors related to these concerns, suggesting key areas for future primary care system development. Objective: Assess specific areas where robust, well-supported primary care could contribute significantly to the health system's pandemic response, & factors that may have prevented it from doing so. Study Design: Online, self-report survey administered over 3 weeks, April-May, 2021. Survey invitations sent via email, with three reminders following initial contact. Setting or Dataset: The College of Family Physicians of Canada (CFPC) membership list was used to reach family physicians in diverse practice settings in all Canadian provinces and territories. Population studied: All active CFPC family physician (FP) members were included. Most FPs in Canada are CFPC members; 39,991 FPs received survey invitations; 3,409 replied, for an overall response rate of 9%. Outcome Measures: Percent of FP engaged in systems level, pandemic response measures, including: 1) reporting COVID-19 cases to public health authorities, 2) identifying priority patients for vaccination, 3) participating in COVID-19 task forces, & 4) contributing to COVID-19 research/clinical studies. Results: Overall, one-third (34%) of FPs say that family practices in their region report COVID-19 cases to public health authorities. Most FPs (55%) say that their practices have not been asked to identify priority cases for COVID-19 vaccination. Less than 1-in-5 (19%) FPs have been involved in COVID-19 advisory/planning committees, task forces or groups. Very few FPs (6%) contribute to COVID-19 research/clinical studies. Half of FPs (50%) are highly concerned about the lack of clarity from government regarding FP response to the pandemic. These findings vary across jurisdictions and practice/remuneration models. Conclusions: Canada's primary care system has not been adequately engaged in important COVID-19 response measures, including monitoring viral spread in the population, pandemic planning, vaccination roll out, and therapeutic research. Practice models and remuneration arrangements are related to primary care's responsiveness to the COVID-19 pandemic,& should be considered in future primary care health system development.
引用
- Snelgrove D, Slade S, Dias E, et al. Pandemic reflection: Significant change is needed to tap into the power of primary care during times of crisis. Ann Fam Med. 2022. PMID: 36706374. doi:10.1370/afm.20.s1.3078
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。