文献速递预防保健、筛查与疫苗慢病管理基层心理健康

黑人患者对新冠疫苗、治疗与检测的看法:初级保健沟通启示

Black patient perceptions of COVID-19 vaccine, treatment, and testing.
PubMed 文献 · Ann Fam Med · 2022-04-01

本研究为定性研究,通过半结构化访谈37名来自四个以黑人患者为主的初级保健诊所的黑人患者,探讨其对新冠疫苗、治疗和检测的看法。结果显示,因历史性医疗不公,患者对疫苗安全性和公平分配高度不信任,倾向等待他人先接种,并偏好居家照护。结论强调 clinician 需留出观察时间、将新干预与已接受的医疗措施相联系,以建立信任。

要点

  • 黑人患者因历史性医疗不公对新冠疫苗安全性与公平分配高度不信任。
  • 患者倾向等待一般人群、权威人物和白人先接种疫苗,并认为防护行为可能更有效。
  • clinician 应留出观察时间、将新冠疫苗与流感疫苗等已接受措施相联系以建立信任。

核心结论

  • 黑人患者的疫苗接种决策取决于是否有足够时间观察疫苗推广并与临床医生讨论。
  • 将新医疗干预与已接受的医疗方法相联系,并意识到医学历史不信任,可指导临床医生赋权并提供优质照护。

研究设计与样本

  • 定性研究,采用归纳与演绎主题分析。
  • 在四个主要服务黑人患者的初级保健诊所招募37名黑人患者,进行45分钟半结构化录音访谈。

主要发现

  • 因医疗系统、医学和研究中的历史性不公,受访黑人患者对新冠疫苗安全性、有效性和公平分配的不信任普遍存在。
  • 患者害怕种族歧视性治疗,打算等待一般人群、权威人物和白人患者先接种疫苗。
  • 许多患者认为个人防护行为(如戴口罩、居家、服用补充剂)比接种新冠疫苗更有效。
  • 患者因高成本和虐待、死亡、孤独风险而偏好居家接受新冠医疗照护。

临床怎么用

  • 临床医生应与黑人患者讨论新冠疫苗时留出足够观察时间,并主动开启对话。
  • 可将新冠疫苗与流感疫苗等患者已接受的医疗措施相联系,以促进理解和接种决策。
  • 临床医生应意识到医学历史不信任的影响,采用反种族主义沟通实践来建立信任。

局限性

  • 原文未报告局限性。

以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。

原文

Context: The Presence for Racial Justice project leverages the Stanford Presence 5 framework to present anti-racism communication practices that promote clinician trust-building for Black patients in primary care. With the racial/ethnic disparities in COVID-19 infection rates, an assessment of Black patients' perspectives around COVID-19 care is required to promote health equity in current and future health crises. Objective: To compile clinician communication strategies for promotion of patient understanding and agency concerning Black patients' perceptions of COVID-19 vaccine, treatment and testing. Study design: Qualitative study employing inductive and deductive thematic analysis. Setting: Four primary care clinics primarily serving Black patients in Oakland, CA; Rochester, NY; Leeds, AL; and Memphis, TN. Population Studied: 37 Black patients, recruited through convenience sampling by their primary care clinician for 45-minute semi-structured audio-recorded interviews. Outcome Measures: Emergent themes around Black patient perceptions and motivations for seeking/delaying COVID-19 vaccine, treatment, and testing, and their ideal medical guidance on COVID-19 care. Results: Due to historic mistreatment of Black patients within the healthcare system, medicine, and research, there is a high prevalence of mistrust amongst the Black patient interviewees towards the safety, efficacy, and equitable distribution of the COVID-19 vaccine compared to existing vaccines. Patients feared racial discriminatory treatment and intended to wait for the general population, authority figures, and White patients to receive the vaccine first. Many patients believed personal protective behaviors (e.g., mask wearing, staying home, taking supplements) would be more effective than receiving the COVID-19 vaccine. They expressed a preference for receiving COVID-19 medical care in the comfort of their homes due to high costs and risks of maltreatment, death, and loneliness. Conclusion: Black patients hinged their vaccination decisions on having enough time to observe vaccine rollout and discussion with their clinicians. Relating new medical interventions (ie., COVID-19 vaccine) to accept medical approaches (ie., Flu vaccine) and being aware of historical distrust in medicine can inform clinician efforts to empower and provide excellent care for Black patients moving forward.

来源:Ann Fam Med,查看原文。版权归原作者所有。

引用

  1. De Leon G, Zulman D, Baratta J, et al. Black patient perceptions of COVID-19 vaccine, treatment, and testing. Ann Fam Med. 2022. PMID: 36706248. doi:10.1370/afm.20.s1.2819

供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。