加拿大安大略省基层医疗虚拟诊疗患者推荐调查
该混合方法研究于2021年2–3月在线调查安大略省534名有基层医疗虚拟就诊经历的患者,评估电话与视频同步虚拟诊疗体验并收集未来使用建议。患者总体体验评分电话75%、视频78%,在节省时间和费用方面获高度认可,多数人希望疫情后至少维持与面诊同等频率的虚拟就诊。
要点
- 电话与视频就诊总体体验评分分别为75%和78%,技术与医患关系维度较高,全人照护维度最低。
- 97%受访者认为虚拟就诊节省时间,81%电话/85%视频认为节省费用,91%认为更方便。
- 69%希望电话、71%希望视频就诊在疫情后至少与面诊一样频繁,仅5%不希望任何虚拟诊疗。
核心结论
- 患者对同步虚拟基层医疗就诊体验总体积极,且受患者与提供者因素影响,患者和提供者或可从支持与培训中获益以优化照护体验。
研究设计与样本
- 混合方法研究,报告与利益相关方共同开发的患者在线调查结果,于2021年2–3月通过社交媒体、患者与照护者组织等网络推广。
- 纳入534名符合条件的受访者,均有至少一次基层医疗虚拟就诊经历;其中402人仅电话、18人仅视频、114人两者均有。
主要发现
- 患者体验总体评分电话75%、视频78%;子维度电话/视频分别为技术92%/84%、医患关系83%/86%、照护质量66%/66%、全人照护43%/53%。
- 电话和/或视频总体评分显著高10%以上的因素包括:非女性(电话8%、视频14%)、法语使用者(13%/16%)、医患关系超过1年(16%/7%)、提供者年龄<50岁(视频15%)、可选择预约时间(15%/21%)。
- 希望向提供者展示问题与较低评分相关(电话-23%)。
- 97%受访者报告电话/视频就诊减少时间,81%/85%报告减少费用,91%/91%认为更方便。
- 69%希望电话、71%希望视频就诊在疫情后至少与面诊一样频繁;仅5%不希望任何未来虚拟诊疗。
临床怎么用
- 在基层医疗中可继续提供电话与视频同步虚拟就诊,并关注全人照护维度的提升。
- 可考虑为患者和提供者提供支持与培训,以优化虚拟就诊体验。
- 安排虚拟就诊时尊重患者对预约时间的选择权,可能有助于提升体验。
局限性
- 调查通过社交媒体等网络推广,受访者以女性、55岁以下、白人、就业、本科及以上、家庭收入>10万加元者为主,代表性有限。
- 研究仅报告调查结果,未评估就诊原因是否影响照护体验(作者表示正在评估)。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
Context: The onset of COVID-19 has required the rapid adoption of virtual services in primary care (PC) practices, and virtual care delivery is likely to continue to some extent post-pandemic. Objective: To understand patient experience with synchronous virtual (telephone (Tel)/Video) appointments and elicit recommendations for its future use. Design: Mixed method, including patient survey co-developed with stakeholders and implemented online Feb-Mar 2021 with large promotional efforts through social media, patient and caregiver organizations, and other networks. We report on the survey results. Eligibility: 1+ virtual encounter in PC. Outcome measures: A) Patient experience scale (12/17 questions for Tel/Video) covering 4 sub-dimensions; B) Access related questions. Questions had 5-point Likert scale items (strongly disagree (-2) to strongly agree (+2)) and were converted into percentage (potential range -100%, +100%) Setting : Ontario, Canada which offers universal coverage for PC visits with no co-payment. Results: 534 eligible respondents (402/18/114 had Tel/Video/both): Females (78%), < 55 years (61%), white (75%), employed (61%), bachelor's degree (74%), family income > 100k (52%). Encounters evaluated were with family physicians (vs other health professionals) for 75%/46% of Tel/Video encounters. A) Patient Experience (Tel/Video) overall score: 75%/78%; Sub-dimensions: technology: 92%/84%, patient-provider relationship: 83%/86%, quality of care: 66%/66%, whole-person care: 43%/53%. Factors associated with a statistically significant(*) > 10% higher overall score in tel and/or video were: non-females: (8%*/14%*), French speaking (13%*/16%*), patient-provider relationship >1 year (16%*/7%), provider age < 50 (5%/15%*), having the choice of appointment time (15%*/21%*). Wanting to show problem to the provider was associated with a lower scores (-23%*/NA). B) Access Respondents overwhelmingly reported that Tel/Video visits reduced time (97%/97%), costs (81%/85%), and was more convenient (91%/91%). The majority wanted Tel (69%) and Video (71%) visits at least as often as in person visits post-covid. Only 5% did not want any future virtual care. Conclusions: Patient experience was largely positive and is influenced by patient/provider factors. Patients and providers may benefit from support/training to optimize care experience. We are now evaluating whether the reasons for visits influences care experience.
引用
- Ashcroft R, Saluja K, Ryan B, et al. Recommendations for virtual care in primary care practices: a survey of patients across Ontario, Canada. Ann Fam Med. 2022. PMID: 36706237. doi:10.1370/afm.20.s1.2947
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。