老年多病共存患者与全科医生共同决策的质性研究
该质性研究通过四组焦点小组(两组≥65岁多病共存患者、两组全科医生),探讨英格兰德文郡全科实践中影响共同决策的因素,发现临床医生的医疗法律脆弱感被医患双方视为共同决策的障碍,并提出了延长咨询时间、改善连续性等促进因素。
要点
- 患者认识到临床医生因医疗法律脆弱感而阻碍共同决策,此为新增发现。
- 医疗法律脆弱感是其他障碍的统一主题,包括指南遵循期望与沟通不确定性困难。
- 延长咨询时间和改善连续性被视为共同决策的促进因素。
核心结论
- 临床医生的医疗法律脆弱感被患者和全科医生共同认为是共同决策的障碍,应加以解决以优化个性化照护。
研究设计与样本
- 质性研究,在英格兰德文郡的农村和城市全科诊所开展四组焦点小组:两组为≥65岁多病共存患者,两组为全科医生,采用归纳编码和主题分析。
主要发现
- 患者承认临床医生在多病共存背景下的医疗法律脆弱感,并将其视为共同决策的障碍,这是一个新发现。
- 医疗法律脆弱感是其他所报告障碍的统一主题,包括对全科医生遵循临床指南的期望、应用指南和沟通临床不确定性时遇到的挑战,以及临床医生对共同决策的自我效能有限。
- 增加咨询时长和改善连续性被视为促进因素。
临床怎么用
- 应解决临床医生的医疗法律脆弱感,以优化个性化照护的提供。
- 需要提高对多病共存指南的认识。
- 应将不确定性沟通教育作为共同决策培训的核心组成部分。
- 应纠正大多数临床医生已有效促进共同决策的错误认知,以提高个性化照护干预的采纳。
以上解读依据论文摘要(全文未开放获取或许可不允许翻译转载)。
原文
BACKGROUND: Shared decision making (SDM), utilising the expertise of both patient and clinician, is a key feature of good-quality patient care. Multimorbidity can complicate SDM, yet few studies have explored this dynamic for older patients with multimorbidity in general practice. AIM: To explore factors influencing SDM from the perspectives of older patients with multimorbidity and GPs, to inform improvements in personalised care. DESIGN AND SETTING: Qualitative study. General practices (rural and urban) in Devon, England. METHOD: Four focus groups: two with patients (aged ≥65 years with multimorbidity) and two with GPs. Data were coded inductively by applying thematic analysis. RESULTS: Patient acknowledgement of clinician medicolegal vulnerability in the context of multimorbidity, and their recognition of this as a barrier to SDM, is a new finding. Medicolegal vulnerability was a unifying theme for other reported barriers to SDM. These included expectations for GPs to follow clinical guidelines, challenges encountered in applying guidelines and in communicating clinical uncertainty, and limited clinician self-efficacy for SDM. Increasing consultation duration and improving continuity were viewed as facilitators. CONCLUSION: Clinician perceptions of medicolegal vulnerability are recognised by both patients and GPs as a barrier to SDM and should be addressed to optimise delivery of personalised care. Greater awareness of multimorbidity guidelines is needed. Educating clinicians in the communication of uncertainty should be a core component of SDM training. The incorrect perception that most clinicians already effectively facilitate SDM should be addressed to improve the uptake of personalised care interventions.
引用
- Brown EL, Poltawski L, Pitchforth E, et al. Shared decision making between older people with multimorbidity and GPs: a qualitative study. Br J Gen Pract. 2022. PMID: 35379603. doi:10.3399/BJGP.2021.0529
供执业医师工作参考,不替代临床判断;数值与分级以指南原文为准。